Video & Transcript Research : 'sunset clause'

Page 100 of 283
MN

Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session

House Health Finance and Policy Committee 5/7/25

Health Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • Section one is a governor initiative to extend the sunset of the drug formulary committee to June 30,
  • Restoring the state's ability to manage the preferred drug list by eliminating the sunset on the drug
  • Restoring the state's ability to manage the preferred drug list by eliminating the sunset on the drug
  • Restoring the state's ability to manage the preferred drug list by eliminating the sunset on the drug
  • Restoring the state's ability to manage the preferred drug list by eliminating the sunset on the drug
Bills: HF2435
NH
Transcript Highlights:
  • When this committee was created, it had a mandatory two-term limit, six years, which is sunsetting now
  • Individuals may serve for six years; the commission doesn't sunset in its entirety in six years.
  • "Individuals may serve for six years; the commission doesn't sunset in its entirety in six years."
  • So if an individual sunsets after six years, presumably nominations are in order for replacement people
  • in its entirety in 6 years sunset in its entirety in 6 years oh<01:33:01.400> I'm<01:33:01.719
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The committee met on March 28 for a Health and Human Services Oversight Committee meeting, approved the draft minutes from February 21, and then received updates from DHHS on the sudden termination of about $80 million in federal COVID-era funding. Commissioner Lori Weaver and Trisha Tilly said the funding had been expected to continue through September 2026, but an email ending it immediately created a 15-month budget gap. They explained that most of the money supported public health work, especially epidemiology, laboratory capacity, data systems, community health workers, outbreak response, and some behavioral health supports. DHHS said it had notified contractors, was reassessing which activities could continue, and had managed to avoid layoffs for its 20 affected staff by shifting funding sources, though some contract lab staff had to leave and some work would stop or be put on hold. Senators and representatives asked about impacts on labs, staffing, and the state budget lapse, and DHHS said the water lab and testing supplies would be affected and that the department was trying to backfill where possible with other federal funds. The committee then heard a maternal mortality report from the Maternal Mortality Review Committee. Alison Power and Caroline Naami explained that the MMRC reviews maternal deaths to identify contributing factors and make recommendations, and that it had completed one CDC grant and received another five years of funding. For 2023, the state recorded five pregnancy-associated deaths, including three from overdose, two from cardiovascular causes, and one homicide; the share of deaths related to substance use fell from 62.5% in 2022 to 40% in 2023. Over the 2019–2023 period, half of pregnancy-related deaths were due to overdose, most occurred postpartum, and many involved Medicaid recipients, transportation or financial barriers, and deaths at home. The committee said mental health and substance use remained the main drivers of maternal mortality, but that 79% of pregnancy-related deaths in the five-year aggregate were considered preventable. Presenters highlighted recommendations and ongoing interventions, including expanding Medicaid coverage through one year postpartum, strengthening behavioral health access, partnering with the Department of Corrections on care for pregnant and postpartum women, and continuing clinical education through the Northern New England Perinatal Quality Improvement Network. Members asked why the maternal mortality rate had declined in recent years; staff said the 2021 spike was tied to the pandemic and that recent declines likely reflected both that spike and the impact of interventions, though the small number of cases makes trends hard to interpret. No additional votes or formal actions were taken beyond approving the minutes.
LA

Louisiana 2026 Regular Session

Senate May 11th, 2026

Louisiana Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • We also put a sunset on it for March 1, 2028. Senator Price has a question on the bill.
  • About the sunset, but I'm done. It's on that. Can you tell them that?
  • Yes, Senator Price, we talked about and committed about the sunset, and you just announced that you have
Bills: SCR63, SCR12, HB89, HB451, HB595, HB617, HB621, HB730, HB1064, HB1125, HB221, HCR58, SB106, SB206, SB248, SB441, SB104, SB122, SB180, SB260, SB424, SB476, SCR9, SCR30, SB57, SB414, SB525, SB35, SB65, SB135, SB215, SB246, SB249, SB269, SB276, SB282, SB296, SB323, SB363, SB369, SB474, SB484, SB490, SB492, SB500, SB501, SB513, HCR31, HB462, HB547, HB613, HB691, HB712, HB720, HB723, HB728, HB735, HB747, HB759, HB825, HB845, HB846, HB903, HB904, HB907, HB923, HB929, HB941, HB962, HB965, HB1036, HB287, HB370, HB515, HB521, HB570, HB1200, HB29, HB39, HB58, HB67, HB73, HB76, HB77, HB82, HB112, HB121, HB125, HB132, HB134, HB151, HB154, HB155, HB161, HB166, HB187, HB191, HB207, HB211, HB224, HB238, HB241, HB242, HB250, HB260, HB265, HB275, HB300, HB320, HB338, HB339, HB349, HB379, HB399, HB427, HB463, HB464, HB468, HB545, HB550, HB551, HB565, HB588, HB639, HB725, HB782, HB805, HB808, HB834, HB847, HB853, HB858, HB861, HB883, HB916, HB937, HB977, HB1012, HB1027, HB1044, HB1054, HB1091, HB1117, HB90, HB127, HB138, HB150, HB201, HB268, HB273, HB285, HB315, HB354, HB355, HB360, HB376, HB445, HB506, HB606, HB649, HB665, HB681, HB721, HB746, HB757, HB781, HB835, HB844, HB857, HB872, HB886, HB889, HB892, HB982, HB987, HB1037, HB1068, HB1072, HB1078, HB1085, HB1132, HB1137, HB1167, HB1174, HB1232, HB1238, HB23, HB136, HB17, HB21, HB51, HB55, HB74, HB106, HB108, HB133, HB140, HB159, HB168, HB215, HB226, HB263, HB296, HB299, HB322, HB364, HB519, HB535, HB538, HB568, HB571, HB622, HB635, HB676, HB772, HB784, HB1006, HB1018, HB1033, HB1034, HB1043, HB1070, HB1134, HB1237, HB1239, HB36, HB119, HB126, HB129, HB245, HB271, HB280, HB337, HB351, HB677, HB726, HB789, HB850, HB956, HB966, SB149, SB382
Summary: The Senate convened with 32 members present, heard a guest prayer from Pastor Dr. Michael Linton, and proceeded through routine journal approval and legislative bureau reports. The chamber received numerous House messages on passed Senate bills and House bills, introduced several resolutions and concurrent resolutions, and recognized Former Legislators’ Day with remarks honoring deceased former members and welcoming back past legislators and other officials. The Senate also adopted SCR 63, which asks the Legislative Auditor to review how fiscal notes are developed and prepared, after an amendment clarifying the study’s scope and a 33-0 vote. The body then took up a series of Senate bills returned from the House. It concurred in House amendments to SB 106 (crime scene recordings/public records), SB 206 (blood pressure testing in schools, narrowed to athletes), SB 248 (polling place closures for very small precincts), SB 104 (highway memorial designation), SB 122 (bridge preservation), SB 180 (disabled veterans’ homestead exemption transfer language), SB 260 (youth athletics safety training/Coach Safely Act), and SB 476 (garnishment service wording). It rejected House amendments to SB 441 on pre-kindergarten programs. SB 57 on nutrition cleanup, SB 414 on medical debt protection, SB 525 on unclaimed property purchases, SB 501 on postsecondary health information postings, and SB 276 on bail bond producer affidavits all advanced or passed, with SB 57 and SB 414 ultimately passing and SB 525 and SB 501 also receiving final passage. The Senate also adopted SCR 30, a resolution urging Congress to ensure accountability and release of Epstein-related files, and later took up SB 513, a pilot program involving average bid/design-build contracting for certain airport-related projects, which passed 25-10 after extended questioning about its purpose and safeguards. SB 484, revising higher education governance and removing LUMCON language in favor of a study commission, passed 36-1. In personal privilege remarks, senators recognized Louisiana Arts Day and introduced guest Ed Tillman. The chamber then began a long series of House bills, including HB 462 on the Capital Area Road and Bridge District board composition, HB 547 on photographing voter registration information, HB 613 on marking driver’s licenses with citizenship status, HB 691 on voter-roll verification through the federal SAVE system, and HB 712 waiving certain OMV fees for homeless individuals; several of these bills were explained and moved toward final passage as the session continued.
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

House Public Safety Finance and Policy Committee 3/17/26

Public Safety Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • Um, has any discussion or thought been given to how that jives with the Fifth Amendment Takings Clause
  • and the whole supremacy clause and the whole supremacy clause conversation<01:04:15.240> that
  • I would say that this runs very far in line with the supremacy clause.
  • . clause. clause.
  • And while I hear<01:18:25.560> the<01:18:25.640> supremacy<01:18:26.120> clause<
NH
Transcript Highlights:
  • And finally there's a separability clause, which, you know, like all other separability clauses, declares
  • And finally there's a separability clause, which, you know, like all other separability clauses, declares
  • Why keep in the clause that says that the pooled risk management programs are not insurers?
  • finally there's a semiraability clause finally there's a semiraability clause uh<00:31:56.320>
  • declares that if one separability clause declares that if one provision<00:32:02.240> in<00:32
Keywords: 1189, house, all
Summary: The subcommittee took up the pooled risk management program bill and reviewed a new amendment drafted with input from the Insurance Department and Legislative Services. Department witnesses explained that the proposal would move oversight of pooled risk management programs from the Secretary of State’s office to the Insurance Department, add a licensure requirement, preserve the programs’ non-insurer status, and exempt them from third-party administrator licensure. They also described a series of solvency tools in the draft, including financial reporting, risk-based capital standards, minimum capitalization, investment limits, commissioner examination and enforcement authority, rulemaking authority, merger and affiliate-transaction review, confidentiality protections, and a separability clause. A major theme of the discussion was that pooled risk management programs differ from commercial insurers because the risk remains with the member local governments rather than being backed by a state guarantee fund. Witnesses said the bill is designed to emphasize solvency over return of premium and to give the Insurance Department a regulatory “toolbox” to prevent insolvency, including a proposed $5 million excess or stop-loss coverage benchmark, optional accessible policies, and a requirement that boards vote on dividends or premium returns when capital exceeds 600% of risk-based capital. Members questioned how this approach differed from the original Secretary of State bill and whether assessments on towns would still be possible; the department responded that the new framework would allow more flexible oversight and alternatives to immediate court action. The committee also discussed why the statute should continue to say the programs are not insurers, with the department explaining that this preserves their autonomy and avoids applying unrelated insurance laws and premium taxes. Members asked about the department’s workload and were told the department believed it could absorb the new duties without additional funding. No vote or final committee action was taken in the portion provided.
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • However, part one, section one of that act sunset in 2024.
  • part one section one of that act sunset part one section one of that act sunset in<00:44:02.200>
  • So they're a really important tool, and this bill would automatically sunset or reduce these types of
  • Then it goes into effect with neither a sunset nor a phase-out, because later legislation prevails over
  • I was looking for is guidance as to how often, and, you know, just the mechanism to review one is sunset
Keywords: 910, house, all
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Taxes - 01/15/25

Taxes

Transcript Highlights:
  • There are some that have sunsets, but the majority of them do not.
  • :18:08.559> have change them there are some that have change them there are some that have sunsets
  • 09.960> majority<00:18:10.360> of<00:18:10.480> them<00:18:10.640> do sunsets
  • but but the majority of them do sunsets but but the majority of them do not<00:18:12.200> unlike<
  • There's a 10-year sunset that we have adopted, and I think especially for new proposals, that is also
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
VT

Vermont 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Session - 2026-02-06 - 11:30AM

Vermont Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • But I would direct our attention to the second whereas clause.
  • So that the clause now reads that the Senate of the State of Vermont, based on initial and substantial
  • So that<00:14:03.920> the<00:14:04.079> clause<00:14:04.480> now<00:14:04.720>
  • > reads<00:14:05.760> that<00:14:06.079> the that the clause now reads that the that
  • the clause now reads that the Senate<00:14:06.639> of<00:14:06.800> the<00:14:06.959><
Keywords: 927, senate, all
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • Additionally, we will also be deleting the be it resolved clause asking the public access room to establish
  • We will also be deleting the last two whereas clauses, as LRB is no longer involved, and we will also
  • by the advisory committee in the resolution so that the be it resolved and be it further resolved clauses
  • , as well as the reporting clause and distribution list, reflect the change.
  • But we will also add a be it resolved clause requesting the County of Hawaii to consider funding the
Keywords: 910, house, all
Summary: The Committee on Education heard three resolutions. STR 53 SD1 sought to have the Legislative Reference Bureau work with the Hawaii State Public Library System to identify rural and underserved communities needing better telecommunications access so residents can participate in the legislative process. Testimony from the Hawaii State Council on Developmental Disabilities supported the measure, emphasizing that many advocates cannot always travel to the Capitol and need better access. STR 117 SD1 urged the Department of Education to work with the Department of Transportation Safe Routes to School Advisory Committee and the County of Hawaii to inventory bus stops on Hawaii Island used by students and develop safety improvements; DOE described an upcoming live route audit, noted the large number of routes and stops on the Big Island, and said some stops are on private roads. The Department of Transportation, Hawaii County Council, the mayor’s office, and others supported the measure, and members discussed whether the effort could eventually expand statewide. STR 134 asked the Department of Education to provide a detailed report on the true cost of producing school meals to improve transparency and avoid unnecessary price increases. DOE said it already tracks food, labor, benefits, supplies, equipment, and other costs to calculate per-meal costs, but does not currently include transportation costs in the same way; it stated its breakfast cost was $5.80 and lunch cost was $8.66. Support testimony came from the Hawaii Public Health Institute, Hawaii Appleseed, the Hawaii Children’s Action Network, the Hawaii Hunger Action Network, and others, who said clearer cost information is especially important amid funding uncertainty. In decision making, the committee amended and passed STR 53 SD1, reverting it to the original draft by replacing the Legislative Reference Bureau with the Controller and adding coordination with the Office of Planning and Sustainable Development and the Hawaii Broadband and Digital Equity Office, while removing references tied to the LRB and the public access room outreach clause. The committee also amended and passed STR 117 SD1, shifting the lead role to the Safe Routes to School Advisory Committee and adding a request for the County of Hawaii to consider funding the effort. STR 134 was passed unamended. Representative Souza was excused for the votes.
TX

Texas 89th Regular

S/C on Defense & Veterans' Affairs Mar 17th, 2025

S/C on Defense & Veterans' Affairs

Transcript Highlights:
  • It is more wisdom to be found than in the clause which confines the question of war or peace to the legislature
  • Congress has passed a declaration. of war or take an official action pursuant to Article 1, Section 8, Clause
  • The Texas Constitution mirrors federal militia clauses, but grants the governor direct authority to call
  • actually Texas defended their position, constitution, something that's very different in that in those clauses
  • But, of course, the Constitution was never amended to say that Article 1, Section 8, Clause 11 was no
WY

Wyoming 2026 Regular Session

House Appropriations Committee, February 13, 2026

Appropriations

Transcript Highlights:
  • To go beyond that would perhaps be a supremacy clause violation.
  • To go beyond that would perhaps be a supremacy clause violation.
  • this bill is a supremacy clause this bill is a supremacy clause violation<00:15:27.440> because
  • perhaps be a supremacy clause violation. perhaps be a supremacy clause violation.
  • It's does violate the supremacy clause.
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • Uh, we'll also insert language to sunset the tax credit in 2036.
  • Uh we'll also insert<01:10:05.600> language<01:10:06.000> to<01:10:06.159> sunset
  • <01:10:06.560> the<01:10:06.800> tax<01:10:07.040> credit insert language to sunset
  • the tax credit insert language to sunset the tax credit in<01:10:07.840> 2036.
  • So the language about the sunset for 2036, we'll just blank that out and insert that into the committee
OK

Oklahoma 2026 Regular Session

Administrative Rules Jan 21st, 2026 at 12:00 pm

Administrative Rules

Transcript Highlights:
  • and it was determined we thought possibly that they were going to ask for the board to go ahead and sunset
  • The sunset is set to expire on July 1, 2026.
  • So we do have four councils that are subject to sunsetting.
  • I'm coming to you today because, as you can see in your paperwork, our OACIE board is on the sunset in
  • For the sunset review, I'll give you an overview.
Keywords: 914, all
TX

Texas 89th Regular

Health and Human Services (Part I) Apr 9th, 2025

Health & Human Services

Transcript Highlights:
  • We have had in the past some abuses, and as you know, with the sunset looked at it, and we put in place
  • Most people don't understand, and you were in this, through Sunset and other things, in this... ...we
  • Most people don't understand, and you were in this, through Sunset and other things, in this...
  • And you were in this, through Sunset and other things, in this committee, that we actually were having
  • That was back in '16, the Sunset Bill, and I was kind of the lead on that, rewriting the Dental Practice
Summary: The Senate Committee on Health and Human Services met with several members initially absent, then later established a quorum. The committee heard multiple bills, with most testimony focusing on access to care, insurance practices, senior safety, and health care worker protections. Several bills were laid out with committee substitutes, and public testimony was limited to two minutes per witness. Most bills were left pending after testimony, with no final votes taken in the portion provided. Senate Bill 2069 would create a work group to study the feasibility of a statewide acute psychiatric bed registry; the substitute shifts appointment authority to the Health and Human Services Commissioner and extends reporting and sunset dates. Senate Bill 463 would expand workplace violence protections to additional hospice, home and community support, intermediate care, and state-supported living center settings. Senate Bill 1283 would require background checks and transparency measures for senior retirement communities after testimony about the Dallas-area serial killings of elderly residents. Senate Bill 1784 would require 60 days’ written notice before medical debt is sent to collections. Senate Bill 527 would require medical insurance coverage for general anesthesia for medically necessary pediatric dental procedures for children under 13 with qualifying conditions; pediatric dentists testified that denials delay needed care. A major portion of the meeting centered on prior authorization. Senate Bill 1380 would eliminate prior authorization for a broad list of services, including emergency, primary, mental health, substance use, chemotherapy, preventive, pediatric hospice, and certain chronic-condition care. Physicians and hospice advocates supported the bill, describing delays, administrative burden, and patient harm, while health plans opposed blanket exemptions and argued prior authorization helps prevent unnecessary care and control costs. Relatedly, Senate Bill 547 would require insurers to report gold-card prior authorization exemptions to TDI and create a centralized database and annual report; TMA supported better tracking, while health plans warned of duplicative reporting and administrative cost. Senate Bill 407 would require health care facilities to honor conscience- and religion-based vaccine exemptions for employees, with testimony from a physician and vaccine-choice advocate supporting the bill. The committee also heard Senate Bill 1383, which would regulate senior living referral agencies, allow more flexible compensation structures, and add disclosure and consumer protections; an out-of-state referral company and A Place for Mom supported it. Senate Bill 1511 would allow freestanding emergency centers to provide outpatient services in addition to emergency care, with consumer protections such as estimates, limits on facility fees, and restrictions on balance billing. The chair repeatedly announced that bills were being left pending after testimony, and no final committee action or recorded votes were taken in the transcript provided.
KY

Kentucky 2026 Regular Session

House Standing Committee on Veterans, Military Affairs, and Public Protection (3-24-26)

Veterans, Military Affairs, & Public Protection

Transcript Highlights:
  • 00:05:15.640> have<00:05:15.760> an<00:05:15.840> emergency<00:05:16.280> clause
  • ,<00:05:16.640> which<00:05:17.080> which it have an emergency clause, which which
  • it have an emergency clause, which which was<00:05:17.360> removed.
  • So, I will be putting a floor amendment on to make put an emergency clause on it so that those troopers
  • on it so that those an emergency clause on it so that those troopers<00:35:54.480> can<00:35:
Keywords: 958, all
LA

Louisiana 2026 Regular Session

Natural Resources and Environment May 19th, 2026

Natural Resources & Environment

Transcript Highlights:
  • They violate the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution, which dictates that— They violate
  • That's a Supremacy Clause issue.
  • So the first thing I mentioned was the Supremacy Clause of the United States.
  • Very likely, yes, violates the Supremacy Clause. What the hell we do in here? I mean...
  • The federal supremacy clause and EPA primacy are not the same thing.
Keywords: 965, house, all
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

House Environment and Agriculture (02/17/2026)

Environment and Agriculture

Transcript Highlights:
  • , into the interstate commerce clause, into the interstate commerce clause, theoretically,<02:49:
  • Forget about the Commerce Clause.
  • Have Forget about the commerce clause.
  • You could violates the commerce clause.
  • We just stop commerce clause in any way.
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The subcommittee held an open work session on HB 1766-FN, a bill addressing cruelty to livestock, and focused on proposed language changes from the Department of Agriculture. Assistant State Veterinarian Nathan Harvey, speaking for the commissioner, explained concerns about the term “imminent danger,” arguing that the bill should allow seizure based on probable cause when an animal is starving or has a life-threatening condition, rather than tying action too closely to whether the owner is arrested. The department also proposed language on “extreme suffering” that would require euthanasia if the cost of treatment would exceed the allowable reimbursement amount under AGR rules, though members immediately raised concerns about using a dollar limit to require euthanasia. The department further suggested clarifying who may participate in investigations by allowing the state veterinarian or a designate, and noted that the current draft could be read too narrowly. Members discussed the $5,000 emergency care cap in the rules, with Josh Marshall confirming it is an aggregate emergency veterinary care limit. Several legislators said they were uncomfortable changing the bill from “may” to “shall” euthanize, arguing that treatment costs vary widely by species and condition and that a fixed monetary threshold could be too rigid. Representative Bixby also raised a separate concern that the bill’s language may be broader than intended and could apply to all animals rather than livestock only. The department agreed the bill should be limited to livestock and suggested using existing statutory definitions or adding a new section to make that clear. The discussion also turned to humane societies and other organizations that might investigate complaints or board seized animals. A representative from a humane organization said the groups with expertise in care often also have expertise useful to investigations, and that removing them entirely could be impractical because only a few facilities in the state can provide boarding. Members and witnesses explored alternative language that would allow for-profit and nonprofit organizations to participate in either the investigation or the care of livestock, but not both, to avoid conflicts of interest while preserving needed expertise. No votes were taken; the work session ended with agreement to consult the Office of Legislative Services and the department to refine the bill before the next meeting.
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

House Environment and Agriculture (02/17/2026)

Environment and Agriculture

Transcript Highlights:
  • Forget about the commerce clause.
  • Forget about the Commerce Clause.
  • Forget about the Commerce Clause.
  • Forget about the Commerce Clause.
  • Forget about the Commerce Clause.
Keywords: 1189, house, all
US

US Federal 2025-2026 Regular Session

US House Floor Proceedings (Tuesday, September 2, 2025)

US Federal House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • Pursuant to clause 12A of rule one, the Chair declares the House in recess until 2:00 p.m.
  • Pursuant to clause 1 of rule 1, the Journal stands approved.
  • Pursuant<02:13:52.880> to<02:13:53.040> clause<02:13:53.520> 12A<02:13:54.560>
  • Pursuant to clause 8 of rule 20, further proceedings on this question will be postponed.
  • <06:36:39.200> Remaining clause nine of rule 20. Remaining clause nine of rule 20.
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • /c><00:53:29.680> add<00:53:29.880> a<00:53:30.160> savings<00:53:30.640> clause
  • <00:53:31.200> so<00:53:31.320> it we should add a savings clause so it we should add
  • a savings clause so it doesn't<00:53:31.680> affect<00:53:32.760> any<00:53:33.000>
  • We'll be adopting AG amendments also to add a savings clause confirming amended sections 1-28.5 HRS does
  • amended sections clause confirming amended sections 1-28.5 1-28.5 1-28.5 HRS<01:06:18.640> does
Keywords: 910, house, all
Summary: The House Committee on Labor met on February 19, 2026, and heard a series of bills largely focused on public employment, staffing, and professional licensing. Early measures included HB 2276 and HB 2472, both relating to Hawaii Employer-Union Health Benefits Trust Fund staff salaries, which were supported by trust fund representatives and received no opposition or questions. The committee also heard HB 1714 HD1 on housing, where the Hawaii Public Housing Authority testified with comments and the Deputy Attorney General raised concerns about the scope of autonomy, civil service, collective bargaining, and a possible separation-of-powers issue involving legislative approval of long-term contracts. The committee then considered several personnel and civil service bills. HB 2325 HD1, relating to civil service exempt positions at DLNR, drew support from DLNR and the Office of Planning and Sustainable Development, but HGEA opposed it and urged the department to seek other recruitment and retention solutions while keeping employees in civil service. HB 1541, relating to Department of Health positions, was supported by DOH on the grounds that the positions serve vulnerable populations and require specialized expertise, while HGEA opposed. HB 2140 HD1, relating to essential permanent positions, received support from OPSD, HGEA, and the Chamber of Commerce, with written comments from the city Department of Budget and Fiscal Services. HB 2315 HD1, relating to state employment benefits, was strongly supported by DOH, UPW, and HGEA as a recruitment and retention incentive; members questioned the pilot program, and DOH explained it would allow employees to cash out vacation leave earlier than current policy allows. The committee also heard HB 2295 on government contracting, with DOE support not present and IBEW 1186 in opposition. HB 1720, relating to professional engineers, drew strong support from the City and County of Honolulu’s planning department, which argued the bill would help with affordable housing review and only affect eligibility to sit for the licensure exam, but strong opposition from engineering industry and licensing board representatives, who warned it would lower licensing standards and harm reciprocity; members questioned both sides about plan review experience and licensure requirements. HB 2367, relating to employment earnings and pay transparency, received strong support from the Hawaii Civil Rights Commission, AAUW, the Commission on the Status of Women, and others, who said transparency helps small businesses and retention, while written opposition came from the Maui Chamber of Commerce and NFIB. Finally, HB 1935, relating to personal information, drew comments from the Attorney General and the Campaign Spending Commission about implementation burdens and disclosure requirements, with UPW supporting the home-address redaction portion but opposing the broader disclosure process; additional written testimony was noted from OIP, the League of Women Voters, Public Press Law Center, HGEA, and DCCA.