New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S05668

Introduced
2/27/25  
Refer
2/27/25  

Caption

Imposes liability for misleading, incorrect, contradictory or harmful information to a user by a chatbot that results in financial loss or other demonstrable harm.

Summary

Bill S05668 aims to amend the General Business Law in New York by establishing liability for proprietors of chatbots that provide false or misleading information to users. The bill defines key terms such as 'chatbot', 'covered user', and 'proprietor', and outlines the responsibilities of chatbot owners in ensuring the accuracy of the information provided. If a chatbot causes financial loss or harm due to misleading information, the proprietor cannot disclaim liability unless they rectify the situation within a specified timeframe. Additionally, the bill includes provisions for companion chatbots, emphasizing the need to prevent self-harm and to protect minors using these technologies.

Impact

The implementation of Bill S05668 will significantly alter the legal landscape for chatbot proprietors in New York. It imposes strict liability on these entities for any harm caused by their chatbots, particularly in cases of self-harm or misinformation. This could lead to increased accountability and a demand for higher standards in chatbot technology and user interaction. The bill also mandates that proprietors take proactive measures to protect users, particularly minors, from harmful content, which may require technological advancements and compliance with new regulations set forth by the attorney general.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill S05668 appears to be cautiously optimistic, with discussions highlighting the importance of user safety and accountability in the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence. However, there are concerns regarding the potential burden this legislation may place on businesses, particularly smaller entities that may struggle to comply with the new requirements. Overall, there is a recognition of the need for regulation in this area, balanced with the need to support innovation.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the potential financial implications for chatbot proprietors, especially smaller companies that may find it challenging to meet the new liability standards. Some stakeholders argue that the bill may stifle innovation by imposing excessive regulatory burdens. Conversely, advocates for the bill emphasize the necessity of protecting users from misinformation and harmful interactions, particularly for vulnerable populations such as minors and individuals at risk of self-harm.

Companion Bills

NY A00222

Same As Imposes liability for misleading, incorrect, contradictory or harmful information to a user by a chatbot that results in financial loss or other demonstrable harm.

Previously Filed As

NY A00222

Imposes liability for misleading, incorrect, contradictory or harmful information to a user by a chatbot that results in financial loss or other demonstrable harm.

IL SB3368

CHATBOT RESPONSE LIABILITY ACT

NY A09317

Regulates companion chatbots by requiring such companion chatbots include a warning.

US HB7985

CHATBOT Act Curbing Harmful AI Tools By Offering Transparency Act

MN HF4452

Artificial intelligence chatbot technology requirements provided, and cause of action for harm created.

MI SB0760

Trade: business regulation; availability of companion chatbots to minors; prohibit. Creates new act.

SD SB168

Regulate the use of chatbots by minors.

MD SB827

Consumer Protection and Product Liability - Chatbots

MN SF4997

Artificial intelligence chatbot technology requirements provision

MD HB1250

Consumer Protection and Product Liability - Chatbots

Similar Bills

OH SB430

Specify that certain actions constitute regulated sports gaming

IL SB3368

CHATBOT RESPONSE LIABILITY ACT

MN SF4997

Artificial intelligence chatbot technology requirements provision

MN HF4452

Artificial intelligence chatbot technology requirements provided, and cause of action for harm created.

NV SB336

Establishes provisions relating to portable benefit accounts. (BDR 53-621)

FL S0604

Portable Benefits Accounts for Independent Contractors and Sole Proprietors

NJ S522

Directs Department of Agriculture to establish Jersey Fresh sales pilot program; appropriates $500,000.

CO HB1101

Criminal Offenses Related to Critical Infrastructure Metals