New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Assembly Bill A05589

Introduced
2/18/25  
Refer
2/18/25  

Caption

Relates to the convening of a human services employee wage board; requires the commissioner of labor to convene a human services employee wage board comprised of twelve members; requires the wage board to hold hearings and report and make recommendations to the governor and legislature no later than December 31, 2027.

Summary

This bill amends the New York Labor Law to create a new Article 19-E establishing a “human services employee wage board.” The Legislature states that many workers employed by nonprofit and other human services providers are paid wages that are insufficient to support themselves and their families, and that state contracting and funding practices have contributed to large pay disparities between human services workers and comparable public- and private-sector employees. The bill frames human services work as essential to the state’s ability to deliver services related to domestic violence, child welfare, homelessness, substance use, mental health, aging, disability services, and other social needs. Under the bill, the Commissioner of Labor must convene a 12-member wage board made up of human services employees, human services providers, provider coalitions, and public appointees. The board must hold public hearings, including multilingual and accessibility accommodations, and may subpoena witnesses and documents, consult with relevant state agencies, and issue a report and recommendations to the governor and legislature by December 31, 2027. The board is directed to examine wage disparities, benefits, poverty-level wages, cost of living, and what wage levels would provide adequate maintenance and protect worker health.

Impact

The bill would add a new statutory framework to the Labor Law for reviewing compensation in the human services sector, specifically affecting nonprofit providers, local agencies, and other entities that receive public funds to deliver human services. It does not itself set wages, but it creates a formal process that could lead to future wage recommendations and labor policy changes under Labor Law sections governing wage boards. If implemented, it would require the Department of Labor to organize hearings, gather testimony and evidence, and transmit recommendations that could influence state contracting, reimbursement rates, and compensation standards for human services workers.

Sentiment

The bill appears strongly supportive of human services workers and is grounded in concerns about low pay, inequity, and the state’s role in driving compensation levels through contracting. The sponsor’s framing emphasizes workforce instability, poverty wages, and racial and gender disparities, suggesting a pro-worker, pro-equity policy goal. No committee transcript or vote record is provided, so there is no recorded opposition or formal vote-based sentiment in the available materials.

Contention

The main policy tension is between improving wages for human services employees and the fiscal implications for the state, local governments, and nonprofit providers that rely on public funding. The bill’s findings criticize underfunding and delayed payments, implying that any wage recommendations could require higher reimbursement rates or new appropriations. Potential points of contention also include the scope of the wage board’s authority, the inclusion of both provider and employee representatives, and whether the state should address compensation through a board process rather than direct wage mandates or contract reforms.

Companion Bills

NY S03953

Same As Relates to the convening of a human services employee wage board; requires the commissioner of labor to convene a human services employee wage board comprised of twelve members; requires the wage board to hold hearings and report and make recommendations to the governor and legislature no later than December 31, 2025.

Previously Filed As

NY A03329

Relates to the convening of a human services employee wage board; requires the commissioner of labor to convene a human services employee wage board comprised of twelve members; requires the wage board to hold hearings and report and make recommendations to the governor and legislature no later than December 31, 2023.

NY S03953

Relates to the convening of a human services employee wage board; requires the commissioner of labor to convene a human services employee wage board comprised of twelve members; requires the wage board to hold hearings and report and make recommendations to the governor and legislature no later than December 31, 2025.

NY A07624

Establishes the human services wage commission for the purpose of investigating whether the wages paid to human services workers are sufficient to provide adequate maintenance and to protect the health and welfare of employees; defines terms; provides for the duties of the commission; requires reporting.

NY A02456

Prohibits employers from requiring low-wage employees to enter into covenants not to compete; requires employers to notify potential employees of any requirement to enter into a covenant not to compete.

NY A09082

Sets base wage requirements for certain human services workers employed in eligible state-funded programs that provide health and/or welfare assistance.

NY A01253

Requires employers to annually report to the division of human rights the number of settlements with employees and other individuals performing services in the workplace regarding claims of discrimination on the basis of sex, including verbal and physical sexual harassment; requires the division of human rights to provide an annual report to the governor and the legislature; makes conforming technical changes.

NY S08337

Sets base wage requirements for certain human services workers employed in eligible state-funded programs that provide health and/or welfare assistance.

NY A09575

Requires annual reports to the governor and the legislature by the franchise oversight board by December thirty-first.

NY A02222

Amends provisions relating to payment of wages to include compensation that is not payable solely at the employer's discretion; requires certain notices.

NY S10215

Requires employers to annually report to the division of human rights the number of settlements with employees and other individuals performing services in the workplace regarding claims of discrimination on the basis of sex, including verbal and physical sexual harassment; requires the division of human rights to provide an annual report to the governor and the legislature; makes conforming technical changes.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.