North Carolina 2023-2024 Regular Session

North Carolina Senate Bill S871

Introduced
5/2/24  
Refer
5/6/24  
Refer
5/9/24  
Report Pass
5/22/24  

Caption

Right To Try Individualized Treatments

Impact

The bill has significant implications for state law as it amends Chapter 90 of the General Statutes to incorporate provisions for individualized treatments. This includes establishing the conditions under which patients can access investigational drugs and protecting healthcare providers from liability when recommending these treatments. Furthermore, it sets up a framework for ensuring informed consent is obtained from eligible patients or their guardians before proceeding with such treatments. As such, it effectively creates a legal avenue for patients seeking alternatives when conventional care is lacking.

Summary

Senate Bill 871, titled "Right To Try Individualized Treatments," aims to provide eligible patients the ability to access individualized investigational drugs, biological products, and devices for the treatment of severe illnesses. The bill outlines the specific criteria that patients must meet to qualify for these treatments, including having a life-threatening or severely debilitating illness and having explored all other approved treatment options. The legislation intends to enhance patient autonomy by granting individuals the right to try potentially beneficial but unapproved treatments when traditional options have failed.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding S871 appears to be generally positive among patient advocacy groups and supporters of medical freedom, who view the bill as a necessary step towards empowering patients with more control over their treatment options. However, there are concerns among some healthcare professionals regarding the safety and efficacy of unapproved treatments, as well as the potential financial implications for patients who might incur significant out-of-pocket costs. The discussion reflects a fundamental tension between the desire for innovation in treatment options and the need to ensure patient safety.

Contention

One notable point of contention is the bill's provision that manufacturers are not required to make individualized drugs available, which critics argue may limit the bill's effectiveness. Additionally, the exclusion of a private right of action against manufacturers could raise questions about accountability if patients experience adverse effects from unapproved treatments. These aspects may provoke debate regarding the balance between promoting access to experimental treatments and ensuring sufficient oversight to protect patients.

Companion Bills

NC H1029

Same As Right To Try Individualized Treatments

Previously Filed As

NC SB594

Relating to right to try individualized treatments

NC HB1270

Patients' Right to Try Individualized Treatments

NC SB33

Right To Try Individualized Treatments Act

NC HF4034

Right to Try Act modified for individualized investigational treatments.

NC A5231

Establishes "New Jersey Right to Try for Individualized Treatments Act."

NC SB250

Enacting the right to try for individualized treatments act to permit a manufacturer to make an individualized investigative treatment available to a requesting patient.

NC H1333

Individualized Investigational Treatments

NC HB1333

Individualized Investigational Treatments :

NC SB933

Health care; creating the Right to Try for Individualized Treatments Act; authorizing individualized investigational treatments for eligible patients. Effective date.

NC SB136

To Create The Right To Try Individualized Investigational Treatment Act; And To Ensure That Patients Have Access To Individualized Investigational Treatment.

Similar Bills

MI HB4412

Mental health: hospitalization; person requiring treatment; revise, and modify certain procedures for treatment. Amends secs. 401, 427, 430, 461, 468, 472a & 475 of 1974 PA 258 (MCL 330.1401 et seq.).

CA AB1779

Alcoholism and drug abuse recovery and treatment programs: inducement of participants.

MI SB0219

Mental health: hospitalization; person requiring treatment; revise, and modify certain procedures for treatment. Amends secs. 401, 427, 430, 461, 468, 472a & 475 of 1974 PA 258 (MCL 330.1401 et seq.).

MI SB0482

Health: patient directives; Michigan medical treatment decisions act; enact. Creates new act.

NM SB33

RIGHT TO TRY INDIVIDUALIZED TREATMENTS ACT

MD SB549

Mental Health - Treatment Plans for Individuals in Facilities - Participation of Family Members or Other Individuals

TX HB975

Relating to the right to try cutting-edge treatments for patients with life-threatening or severely debilitating illnesses.

TX SB984

Relating to access to individualized investigational treatments for patients with life-threatening or severely debilitating illnesses.