Montana 2023 Regular Session

Montana House Bill HB895

Introduced
3/24/23  

Caption

Constitutional amendment to require legislative approval of redistricting plan

Impact

If approved, HB 895 will lead to changes in how district boundaries are drawn within Montana, shifting some power from the citizen's commission to the legislature. This could affect the balance of power in the legislative process, as the legislature may use its approval process to influence districting outcomes. The bill also proposes a two-thirds vote requirement for passage, thereby ensuring that substantial consensus is necessary for any changes to be made to redistricting plans. The measure is designed to foster bipartisan cooperation in the redistricting process.

Summary

House Bill 895 is a legislative proposal aimed at amending Article V, Section 14 of the Montana Constitution. The primary focus of the bill is to require legislative approval for any state legislative redistricting plan. The bill proposes a significant change to the redistricting process by ensuring that the plans prepared by a citizen's commission will not automatically become law upon filing but will first require the legislature's approval. Supporters argue that this process will enhance transparency and accountability within the redistricting process.

Contention

While proponents view the bill as a necessary step for improving the democratic processes involved in redistricting, opponents express concerns about the potential for political manipulation. They fear that granting legislative approval might lead to partisan gerrymandering and create districts that favor specific political interests over fair representation. Additionally, there is apprehension among some lawmakers regarding the effectiveness of the commission process if it is subjected to legislative approval, undermining the citizen involvement that is currently a part of the redistricting process.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

MT SJR42

Constitutional amendment; vesting the power of redistricting with the Citizens' Independent Redistricting Commission.

MT SF3513

Constitutional Amendment establishing an Independent Redistricting Commission

MT HF3270

Independent Redistricting Commission established, Redistricting Commission Applicant Review Panel established, principles to be used in adopting legislative and congressional districts established, former legislative members lobbying activity prohibited, legislative session conduct and convening requirements amended, and constitutional amendment proposed.

MT SF824

Constitutional Amendment establishing a Bipartisan Redistricting Commission

MT HJR2006

A joint resolution proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the State of Iowa relating to legislative redistricting.

MT S6

Proposal for a legislative amendment to the Constitution establishing an independent redistricting commission

MT HJR135

Proposing a constitutional amendment establishing the Texas Redistricting Commission to redistrict the Texas Legislature and Texas congressional districts and revising procedures for redistricting.

MT HF550

Bipartisan Redistricting Commission established, principles to be used in adopting legislative and congressional districts established, and constitutional amendment proposed.

MT SJR11

Proposing a constitutional amendment establishing the Texas Redistricting Commission to redistrict the Texas Legislature and Texas congressional districts and revising procedures for redistricting.

MT HJR1001

A Constitutional Amendment To Create The Citizens' Redistricting Commission And To Repeal The Board Of Apportionment.

Similar Bills

AR SB425

To Amend Various Provisions Of The Arkansas Code Concerning Enhanced Transportation; And To Declare An Emergency.

TX HB5663

Relating to the authority of the Wood County Central Hospital District of Wood County, Texas, to provide brain and memory care services to residents of the hospital district through the creation and operation of brain and memory health care services districts.

KY HR1

A RESOLUTION establishing the 2026 membership of the Kentucky State House of Representatives.

KY HR1

A RESOLUTION establishing the 2025 membership of the Kentucky State House of Representatives.

LA HB719

Provides relative to the number of assistant district attorneys in each judicial district (RE +$2,274,000 GF EX See Note)

KY HR1

A RESOLUTION establishing the 2022 membership of the Kentucky State House of Representatives.

LA SB454

Provides for a population based allocation of assistant district attorney positions in the state. (7/1/26) (OR +$397,950 GF EX See Note)

VA HB29

Chaptered