Massachusetts 2023-2024 Regular Session

Massachusetts House Bill H3856

Introduced
5/15/23  

Caption

Relative to coercive control occurring between family or household members

Impact

The introduction of this bill could significantly impact state law by expanding the legal parameters of what constitutes abuse, thereby allowing for more comprehensive protection of individuals in domestic situations. By formalizing coercive control as a recognized form of abuse, the bill may empower victims to seek legal recourse and support. It could also influence how law enforcement and the judicial system respond to domestic abuse cases, as officers and judges will need to be trained in recognizing and addressing coercive control behaviors as part of their legal obligations during cases of family violence.

Summary

House Bill 3856 aims to amend Chapter 209A of the General Laws in Massachusetts to introduce a clear definition of 'coercive control' as a form of abuse occurring between family or household members. This bill intends to broaden the legal understanding of abuse to encompass behaviors that control or regulate a family member's life in a coercive manner. Recognizing coercive control is pivotal as it brings attention to emotional and psychological dimensions of abuse that have often been overlooked in legal contexts. The bill's provisions seek to protect family members from various forms of control, including isolation, deprivation of necessities, and threats of physical harm or sexual acts.

Contention

Despite the potential protections offered by H3856, the bill may face contention regarding the implications of defining coercive control within the legal framework. Critics could argue that the subjective nature of coercive behaviors may lead to challenges in enforcement and interpretation. Furthermore, there might be concerns about how such a definition could impact family law cases, particularly in relation to child custody and visitation rights. Ensuring adequate support and education around coercive control for law enforcement, legal professionals, and the public becomes essential to the bill's successful implementation.

Companion Bills

MA S1097

Similar To Relative to coercive control

MA H1542

Similar To To protect victims of coercive control

MA H4115

Replaced by To prevent abuse and exploitation

Previously Filed As

MA HB96

AN ACT relating to coercive control.

MA HB2087

Relating To Abuse Of Family Or Household Members.

MA SB2254

Relating To Abuse Of Family Or Household Members.

MA S0702

Criminal Coercive Control

MA HB4659

DOMESTIC VIOL-COERCIVE CONTROL

MA S0588

Criminal Coercive Control

MA HB5336

Relating to coercive control in domestic violence

MA S08633

Relates to coercive control; provides that the family court and the criminal courts shall have concurrent jurisdiction over acts which constitute coercive control; provides that courts may issue orders of protection upon a finding of coercive control; directs the office of court administration, in consultation with the office for the prevention of domestic violence and certain organizations, to develop and administer training for judges and court clerks on coercive control.

MA A09551

Relates to coercive control; provides that the family court and the criminal courts shall have concurrent jurisdiction over acts which constitute coercive control; provides that courts may issue orders of protection upon a finding of coercive control; directs the office of court administration, in consultation with the office for the prevention of domestic violence and certain organizations, to develop and administer training for judges and court clerks on coercive control.

MA A11182

Provides that the use of threats or harm to animals shall be considered a means of coercion or coercive control.

Similar Bills

CA AB998

An act to amend Sections 25160.

NJ A3124

Establishes NJ Affordable Connectivity Program to provide discounted broadband services to certain households; appropriates $10 million.

CA AB2689

Low-income housing tax credits: lease nonrenewal: good cause.

IL HB3616

IHDA-AFFORDABLE HOUSING EXEMPT

NJ A5198

Facilitates changes to certain terms of State or federal tenant-based housing subsidy due to increase in household members, emergency conditions, and financial barriers faced by head-of-household.

NJ A3422

Establishes limits for electric public utility rate increases for low- and middle-income households.

NJ S724

Establishes limits for electric public utility rate increases for low- and middle-income households.

CA SB548

California Overdose Death and Addiction Reduction Act of 2025.