Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa Senate Bill SF2320

Introduced
2/14/24  

Caption

A bill for an act relating to contracts between a publisher and a library for electronic literary materials, and providing civil penalties.(Formerly SF 2230.)

Impact

The legislation significantly impacts library operations by securing their ability to lend electronic resources without arbitrary publisher-imposed restrictions. This would empower libraries across Iowa to adapt and serve their communities more effectively by enhancing access to educational and literary resources. As of July 1, 2024, any new or renewed agreements between publishers and libraries would need to comply with these regulations, thereby affecting the structure and terms of current publishing agreements.

Summary

Senate File 2320 aims to establish guidelines governing contracts between libraries and publishers of electronic literary materials. The bill seeks to prevent common restrictions that may hinder libraries' operational functions, ensuring they can perform their customary lending practices without undue limitation from publishers. Specifically, it prohibits contracts that restrict libraries from loaning electronic materials, limits on the number of borrowers, and any clauses that prevent libraries from making nonpublic preservation copies or sharing contract terms with other libraries.

Contention

One point of contention surrounding SF2320 could be the balance of power between publishers and libraries. While advocates argue that the bill strengthens libraries' abilities to serve their communities, publishers may contend that such restrictions undermine their rights to control the distribution and access to their materials. The bill also grants the attorney general enforcement authority, which includes the ability to impose civil penalties up to one hundred thousand dollars for violations, potentially creating friction between these parties and influencing the broader conversation on intellectual property rights and access to digital content.

Companion Bills

IA SF2230

Similar To A bill for an act relating to contracts between a publisher and a library for electronic literary materials, and providing civil penalties.(See SF 2320.)

Previously Filed As

IA HF466

A bill for an act relating to contracts between a publisher and a library for electronic literary materials, and providing civil penalties.

IA S09339

Protects library access to electronic literary materials by prohibiting certain restrictive provisions in contracts between publishers and libraries.

IA A09625

Permits libraries and library systems to enter into cooperative purchasing agreements to purchase or license electronic literary materials; prevents contracts between publishers or aggregators and libraries or library systems from restricting the disclosure of certain information.

IA S1674

Prohibits contracts for procurement and licensing of electronic literary materials from including certain provisions.

IA A4956

Prohibits contracts for procurement and licensing of electronic literary materials from including certain provisions.

IA A03589

Protects library access to electronic literary materials by prohibiting certain restrictive provisions in contracts between publishers and libraries.

IA HB2577

Relating To Licensing Of Electronic Literary Material.

IA HF3698

Certain terms in libraries' electronic book and digital audiobook license agreements or contracts prohibited.

IA SF3685

Certain libraries' electronic book and digital audiobook license agreements or contracts terms prohibition

IA SB01234

An Act Prohibiting Libraries From Agreeing To Certain Terms In Electronic Book And Digital Audiobook License Agreements Or Contracts.

Similar Bills

HI HB2577

Relating To Licensing Of Electronic Literary Material.

NJ S1674

Prohibits contracts for procurement and licensing of electronic literary materials from including certain provisions.

NJ A4956

Prohibits contracts for procurement and licensing of electronic literary materials from including certain provisions.

DC B26-0490

Library E-book Pricing Fairness Amendment Act of 2025

CT SB01234

An Act Prohibiting Libraries From Agreeing To Certain Terms In Electronic Book And Digital Audiobook License Agreements Or Contracts.

CT HB06958

An Act Making Certain Terms In Electronic Book And Digital Audiobook License Agreements Or Contracts Unenforceable.

IA HF466

A bill for an act relating to contracts between a publisher and a library for electronic literary materials, and providing civil penalties.

RI S2525

Establishes enforcement limitations on contract terms for the licensing of electronic books or digital audiobooks to libraries to preclude the library from being subject to unfair sales practices.