To require that all United States Congressional Representatives, United States Senators, federal judges, and cabinet secretaries be natural born United States citizens.
Impact
If passed, HCR73 would represent a significant shift in the regulations governing federal office holders by tightening the criteria for eligibility. Through this resolution, the West Virginia legislature aims to unify efforts among states to propose similar amendments, effectively pursuing a collective approach to constitutional change. This could have implications on future nominations and appointments at the federal level, potentially limiting opportunities for naturalized citizens to hold significant government positions compared to their natural born counterparts.
Summary
House Concurrent Resolution 73 (HCR73) seeks to urge Congress to convene a convention of states, as authorized by Article V of the U.S. Constitution. The resolution specifically proposes amendments that would mandate all members of the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate, as well as federal judges and cabinet secretaries, to be natural born citizens of the United States with sole and exclusive U.S. citizenship. This push is in line with ongoing national discussions concerning the qualifications required for federal office holders.
Sentiment
The sentiment surrounding HCR73 appears to be favorable among its proponents who view it as a necessary step to ensure that individuals in high-power roles possess a strong allegiance to the United States. Supporters argue that this will strengthen the integrity of the nation’s governance. Conversely, critics may challenge the resolution on the grounds of fairness towards naturalized citizens, arguing that it creates an unnecessary barrier that could be viewed as discriminatory, potentially hindering talent and diversity in government.
Contention
Notable points of contention arise from the implications of restricting federal positions exclusively to natural born citizens. This perspective raises debates about citizenship's role in a modern democracy, where numerous naturalized citizens have proven themselves as effective leaders and public servants. Concerns about politicization of citizenship status and potential adverse effects on democratic inclusiveness are likely to continue as the conversations surrounding HCR73 evolve, reflecting broader national dialogues on immigration and citizenship.
Expiring funds to the unappropriated surplus balance in the State Fund, General Revenue, from the Department Revenue, State Budget Office, PEIA Rainy Day Fund
To require that all United States Congressional Representatives, United States Senators, federal judges, and cabinet secretaries be natural born United States citizens.
Elections: registration; verification of an elector's United States citizenship; require, and modify voter identification requirements. Amends secs. 1 & 4, art. II of the state constitution.