West Virginia 2022 Regular Session

West Virginia House Bill HB4346

Introduced
1/24/22  

Caption

Relating to the authority and obligations of the Governor and Legislature when in declared states of preparedness and emergency

Impact

The proposed legislation significantly impacts existing statutes governing emergency response in West Virginia. By delineating the powers of the Governor during emergencies, it restricts local governance's role in emergency management while providing a framework for cooperation between state-level authorities and local organizations. Furthermore, the bill stipulates that states of preparedness and emergency can only last for a maximum of 60 days, unless extended by legislative resolution. This introduces a system of checks by requiring legislative approval for extended emergency measures.

Summary

House Bill 4346 aims to clarify the authority and obligations of the Governor and the Legislature in West Virginia during declared states of preparedness and emergency. It provides specific requirements for proclamations related to such states, establishing new criteria for their duration and termination. The bill also outlines emergency powers that the Governor may exercise, allowing for enhanced operational control during emergencies, including the purchase of necessary materials and the regulation of essential services.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 4346 appears mixed. Proponents argue that the bill is essential for effective state response to crises, providing clarity in governance during emergencies. However, opponents express concerns regarding the potential for overreach, fearing that the significant authority granted to the Governor could undermine democratic oversight and local autonomy. This tension between necessary action in emergencies and safeguarding public rights is central to the discourse surrounding the bill.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the powers granted to the Governor over local jurisdictions, particularly regarding the ability to enforce regulations without local input. Critics worry that this could lead to excessive control by the state government, especially in areas traditionally managed by local authorities. Additionally, the bill explicitly states that the Governor cannot dictate practices within places of worship during emergencies, which has raised discussions concerning religious freedom and the limits of state intervention during crises.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

WV SB829

Modifying classes of state of preparedness declared by Governor or Legislature

WV SB66

Modifying classes of state of preparedness declared by Governor or Legislature

WV HB3423

Clarifying the declaration of a State of Preparedness by executive orders of the Governor or by concurrent resolution of the Legislature.

WV HR302

Statement of the sentiments of the House of Delegates upon passage of HB 302, West Virginia’s law governing abortion

WV S7040

Emergency Preparedness and Response Fund/Executive Office of the Governor

WV HB4306

Relating to authorizing the Board of Osteopathic Medicine to promulgate a legislative rule relating to emergency temporary permits to practice during States of Emergency or States of Preparedness.

WV SB951

Relating to the authority of the governor and the legislature regarding declared states of disaster.

WV HB274

Provides relative to the Governor's Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness (EN SEE FISC NOTE GF EX)

WV SB357

Board of Osteopathic Medicine rule relating to emergency temporary permits to practice during states of emergency or states of preparedness

WV HB523

Relating to the authority of the legislature, courts, the governor, and other state and local officials regarding declared states of disaster.

Similar Bills

CA AB846

An act to add Article 3.

CA AB300

An act to amend Sections 51178 and 51181 of the Government Code, and to amend Sections 4202 and 4204 of the Public Resources Code, relating to land use.

NJ A2611

Requires DOH to establish Regional Hospital System Program for Emergency Preparedness and to annually survey preparedness and resiliency of State's hospital system in event of public emergency.

CA SCR97

California Emergency Preparedness Month.

AR HB1250

To Create A Sales Tax Holiday For Disaster-preparedness Supplies To Encourage Disaster-preparedness.

CA AB758

Wildfire: vegetation management.

NC H665

DPI Disaster Preparedness Fund

NC HB665

House Bill 665