John Simmons — Representative Butz responds directly to Representative Simmons.
John Simmons — Voted yes as Vice Chair Simmons.
John Simmons — Voted yes.
Kemp Strickler — Was called during the roll call.
Kemp Strickler — Called on or referenced in the flow of discussion.
Kemp Strickler — Called on after Representative Simmons' comments.
Kemp Strickler — Called on to speak.
Kemp Strickler — Commented that vehicle depreciation starts steeply and then levels out, comparing it to the current approach.
Kemp Strickler — Votes no.
Kemp Strickler — Votes no.
Kemp Strickler — Representative Strickler is called on for discussion; the chair and member clarify the pronunciation of his name.
Kemp Strickler — Referenced as the minority leader of the committee.
Kemp Strickler — Voted no.
Steve Butz — Was called during the roll call; the transcript appears to have autocorrected his name as 'Bucks.'
Steve Butz — Votes no.
Steve Butz — Votes no.
Steve Butz — Chair recognizes Representative Butz to proceed.
Steve Butz — Begins responding to Representative Simmons and references another committee hearing on eliminating the state income tax.
Steve Butz — Argues that Democrats have already been reducing taxes, including the state income tax, over the last seven or eight years.
Steve Butz — Says the legislature should wait to see the effects of prior tax cuts before making more changes.
Steve Butz — Reiterates that taxes have already been cut and asks colleagues to acknowledge it.
Steve Butz — Voted no.
Brad Christ — Was called during the roll call; the transcript appears to have shortened his name to 'Chris.'
Brad Christ — Brad Christ votes yes in the roll-call vote.
Brad Christ — Voted yes.
Mike Costlow — Was called during the roll call; the transcript appears to have transcribed his name as 'Kastlow.'
Mike Costlow — During the roll call, the member’s name is unclear and appears to be a misheard or uncertain reference to Mike Costlow ('Paslow?'), with the vote or response not clearly captured.
Mike Costlow — Vote was unclear in the transcript.
Will Jobe — Was called during the roll call; the transcript appears to have transcribed his name as 'Job.'
Will Jobe — Called during the roll and again in the continuation of the roll call.
Will Jobe — Thanked the chair and then was recognized to proceed.
Will Jobe — Raised concerns about the amendment's effect, estimating the value would drop to about 72%.
Will Jobe — Questioned whether the language would be applied as intended and said the proposal seemed too complicated.
Will Jobe — Suggested a simpler depreciation formula instead of a chart and setoff.
Will Jobe — Warned that the two-step chart could confuse people and lead to unintended results.
Will Jobe — Referenced in agreement with the discussion on the depreciation schedule.
Will Jobe — Referenced as part of the discussion about how the chart and depreciation schedule are read.
Will Jobe — Speaker is identified as Representative Jobe in the transcript.
Will Jobe — Referenced indirectly as having pushed a property tax bill relevant to the broader issue.
Will Jobe — Name is unclear in the roll call; likely intended to be Jobe, but the vote is not clearly captured.
Will Jobe — Name is unclear in the roll call; likely intended to be Jobe, but the vote is not clearly captured.
Will Jobe — Vote was unclear in the transcript, though the text appears to indicate no.
Ben Keathley — Ben Keathley was called during the roll call, with his name appearing in the transcript as 'Keithley' and then again as 'Keathley?' in the continuation of the same roll call.
Ben Keathley — Called on to speak after the explanation of the amendment.
Ben Keathley — Ben Keathley votes yes.
Ben Keathley — Voted yes.
Jeff Coleman — Votes aye as chair.
Jeff Coleman — Jeff Coleman, acting as Chairman Coleman, participated in the roll call and voted aye.
John Simmons — Was called during the roll call as Vice Chair.
John Simmons — Referenced as having done the approach being discussed.