Virginia 2024 Regular Session

Virginia Senate Bill SJR18

Introduced
1/9/24  

Caption

Dillon Rule; joint subcommittee to study.

Impact

The creation of this subcommittee could lead to fundamental shifts in local governance across Virginia. By potentially abrogating or modifying the Dillon Rule, the joint subcommittee could provide local governments with greater authority and flexibility in addressing specific needs and concerns unique to their communities. This could empower local officials to enact policies that better reflect the desires and necessities of the citizens they represent, contrasting with the current limitations placed upon them by state laws.

Summary

SJR18 is a legislative joint resolution aimed at establishing a subcommittee tasked with studying the Dillon Rule in Virginia. The Dillon Rule, which is a principle of statutory interpretation that limits local government powers to those explicitly granted by state laws, has been a significant aspect of Virginia's governance. As localities face increasingly complex issues, some argue that this rule hinders their operational capacity and does not reflect the modern needs of governance. The proposed study will examine whether transitioning from the Dillon Rule framework to a home rule structure might better serve Virginia's localities.

Contention

Among the points of contention surrounding SJR18 is the debate between advocates for more robust local autonomy and those who support maintaining the status quo of the Dillon Rule. Proponents of the study argue that local governments should have the ability to respond dynamically to community needs without being constrained by state limitations. Conversely, critics may worry about the risks associated with increased local power, such as inconsistent regulations across the state, which could affect investments and uniformity in policy implementation. The resolution highlights a significant turning point in the discussion regarding local versus state authority in governance.

Companion Bills

VA HJR24

Similar To Dillon Rule; joint subcommittee to study.

Previously Filed As

VA SJR18

Dillon Rule; joint subcommittee to study.

VA HJR24

Dillon Rule; joint subcommittee to study.

VA SJR253

General elections; joint subcommittee to study consolidation and scheduling.

VA HJR443

Consolidation and scheduling of general elections; joint subcommittee to study.

VA HJR16

Recurrent Flooding, Joint Subcommittee on; study continued.

VA HJR28

Hampton Rds.; joint subcommittee to study public transit systems to ensure it meets needs of region.

VA HJ16

Continuing the Joint Subcommittee on Recurrent Flooding. Report.

VA HJR437

Recurrent Flooding, Joint Subcommittee on; reestablished and its work continued.

VA HJR25

Historically black colleges and universities; joint subcommittee to study challenges faced, etc.

VA HJR024

Joint Rules Resolution - Appropriations Subcommittee Amendments

Similar Bills

IN SB0001

Abortion.

NV AB328

Creates certain commissions and subcommittees for the purpose of educating the general public concerning certain cultural affairs relating to African-Americans. (BDR 18-619)

DE SB289

An Act To Amend Title 29 Of The Delaware Code Relating To The State Employee Benefits Committee.

TX HB1119

Relating to a biennial report on the regional allocation of mental health beds.

TX HB321

Relating to implementing an express lane option under Medicaid and the child health plan program.

TX HB3575

Relating to the filing of a campaign treasurer appointment and an application for a place on the ballot by a candidate for the board of directors of an appraisal district.

TX HB1533

Relating to the system for appraising property for ad valorem tax purposes.

TX HB2786

Relating to the frequency with which certain appraisal districts are required to reappraise property for ad valorem tax purposes and to a limitation on the authority of an appraisal district to increase the appraised value of property.