Tennessee 2023-2024 Regular Session

Tennessee House Bill HB1027

Introduced
1/30/23  

Caption

AN ACT relative to the bust of Nathan Bedford Forrest in the Tennessee State Museum.

Impact

By moving the bust and removing taxpayer funding responsibilities, the bill alters the relationship between public funding and memorials associated with controversial historical figures. This change could set a precedent for how similar monuments are treated in the future, possibly limiting public involvement in the management of such historical markers. The bill is expected to influence statutes related to the management of state-held historical artifacts, aligning with broader discussions about how states honor or disassociate from figures involved in racial and historical conflicts.

Summary

House Bill 1027 proposes to relocate the bust of Nathan Bedford Forrest, which has been housed in the Tennessee State Museum, to the headquarters of the Sons of Confederate Veterans in Columbia, Tennessee. This bill mandates that taxpayer funds will no longer be used for the care, display, or maintenance of the bust, which was donated by the Sons of Confederate Veterans in 1977. The financial responsibility for the bust's relocation falls entirely on the Sons of Confederate Veterans and not on the state or its taxpayers, indicating a shift in how historical monuments tied to contentious figures are managed in Tennessee.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 1027 is polarized. Supporters, often aligned with the Sons of Confederate Veterans and certain political groups, view the bill as a means of honoring heritage and ensuring that communities maintain control over their historical narratives. In contrast, opponents argue that it represents an endorsement of divisive historical figures and could diminish the state's accountability in addressing its history. The discussions reflect ongoing tensions regarding how historical memory is constructed and who decides its portrayal in public spaces.

Contention

Notable points of contention revolve around the legacy of Nathan Bedford Forrest, a figure controversial for his association with the Confederacy and alleged involvement in racist acts. The debate over the bill highlights broader societal conflicts regarding the commemoration of Confederate leaders and the implications for racial reconciliation. Critics emphasize that moving the bust to a privately funded location does not resolve the underlying issues of racial and historical sensitivity, raising questions about the appropriateness of honoring such figures.

Companion Bills

TN SB1097

Crossfiled AN ACT relative to the bust of Nathan Bedford Forrest in the Tennessee State Museum.

Previously Filed As

TN SCR75

MUSEUMS: Directs the Louisiana Department of Culture, Recreation and Tourism, in consultation with the Louisiana State Museum Board and the National WWII Museum, to conduct a study on the feasibility of establishing a museum and trail dedicated to the Louisiana Maneuvers.

TN SB1254

AN ACT to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 4; Title 8; Title 9; Title 10; Title 11 and Title 12, relative to museums.

TN HB1388

AN ACT to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 4; Title 8; Title 9; Title 10; Title 11 and Title 12, relative to museums.

TN SB210

Provides relative to state museums. (8/1/25) (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

TN HB2258

To designate the Maine Forest and Logging Museum, located in Bradley, Maine, as the National Museum of Forestry and Logging History.

TN HB108

Provides relative to the position of museum director for the Louisiana State Museum

TN SB2663

Veterans; allow free admission to state parks and museums.

TN SB0066

AN ACT to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 4, Chapter 20, Part 3 and Title 4, Chapter 29, relative to the Douglas Henry state museum commission.

TN HB0244

AN ACT to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 4, Chapter 20, Part 3 and Title 4, Chapter 29, relative to the Douglas Henry state museum commission.

TN SB27

Revises provisions relating to museums. (BDR 33-281)

Similar Bills

SC H4440

James Gallman

PA SR79

Recognizing April 12, 2025, as the 161st anniversary of the Fort Pillow Massacre, in honor of the fallen soldiers who lost their lives during this battle.

US HB763

James J. Andrews and William H. Campbell Congressional Gold Medal ActThis bill provides for the award of a single Congressional Gold Medal in commemoration of James J. Andrews and William H. Campbell to recognize their bravery and devotion during the Civil War as the only civilian members of Andrews’ Raiders, who launched a daring military raid that became known as the Great Locomotive Chase.

MS SC504

Extend sincerest sympathy of Mississippi Senate to surviving family of former Senator Charles Pittman.

TN HJR1062

A RESOLUTION to commemorate Motorcycle Safety and Awareness Month in Tennessee, May 2026.

TN HJR0547

A RESOLUTION to commemorate Motorcycle Safety and Awareness Month in Tennessee, May 2025.

MT HR8

House resolution recognizing history of racism and bigotry within democratic party

TN HJR1518

A RESOLUTION to honor and commend Barry Clingan upon his recognition by the East Tennessee Historical Association as a member of the First Families of Tennessee.