South Carolina 2025-2026 Regular Session

South Carolina House Bill H5004

Introduced
1/22/26  

Caption

A BILL TO AMEND THE SOUTH CAROLINA CODE OF LAWS BY AMENDING SECTION 39-5-39, RELATING TO AN ATTORNEY ADVERTISING IN A FALSE, DECEPTIVE, OR MISLEADING MANNER, SO AS TO DEFINE FALSE ADVERTISING; TO PROVIDE THAT ANY ADVERTISING FOR LEGAL SERVICES THAT REFERENCES A SETTLEMENT OBTAINED ON BEHALF OF A CLIENT MUST DISCLOSE THE AMOUNT OF ATTORNEY FEES AND LITIGATION COSTS DEDUCTED FROM THE RECOVERY; TO REQUIRE THE LEGAL ADVERTISEMENT TO CLARIFY THAT ANY REFERENCED RESULTS ARE NOT REPRESENTATIVE OF ALL CASES AND THAT OUTCOMES DEPEND ON THE SPECIFIC FACTS OF EACH CASE; AND TO PROVIDE THAT ANY ADVERTISING FOR LEGAL SERVICES THAT STATES THAT THE FILING OF A LAWSUIT IS AGAINST AN INSURANCE COMPANY OR OTHER THIRD PARTY MUST DISCLOSE THE FACT THAT ANY LAWSUIT WOULD BE FILED AGAINST AN INDIVIDUAL OR BUSINESS THAT WOULD BE NAMED AS THE DEFENDANT AND THAT THE INSURANCE COMPANY IS ONLY PROVIDING THE COVERAGE ON BEHALF OF THE NAMED INDIVIDUAL OR BUSINESS BASED ON A POLICY PURCHASED BY THE INDIVIDUAL OR BUSINESS.

Impact

If enacted, this bill would have a significant impact on the legal advertising landscape in South Carolina. It aims to protect consumers by ensuring they have accurate expectations about the services provided by attorneys. This approach is likely to reduce misleading claims about outcomes in legal advertisements and foster a more ethical standard in the legal profession. By mandating clear disclosures in advertisements, the bill promotes informed decision-making among clients seeking legal assistance.

Summary

House Bill 5004 seeks to amend Section 39-5-39 of the South Carolina Code of Laws concerning false or misleading advertising by attorneys. The bill defines what constitutes false advertising in the context of legal services, emphasizing the importance of transparency with prospective clients regarding outcomes and attorney fees. It stipulates that any advertising referencing a specific settlement amount must disclose how much of that amount went to attorney fees and litigation costs, making financial obligations clear to potential clients.

Contention

Notably, there may be contention surrounding this bill regarding the balance between regulating advertising practices and allowing attorneys to market their services competitively. Some practitioners may argue that such restrictions could limit their ability to effectively communicate their successes to potential clients. Additionally, while the bill aims to safeguard consumers, there may be concerns about how these regulations could impact the advertising strategies of smaller law firms as they navigate the requirements to remain compliant while still trying to attract clients.

Companion Bills

SC S0821

Similar To Lawyer Advertising Unfair Practice

Previously Filed As

SC H3404

Ensuring Likeness, Voice, and Image Security Act

SC H5247

Provides that advertising goods that don't include a price referencing all mandatory fees and charges shall be a deceptive trade practice.

SC S0017

Provide that advertising goods that don't include a price referencing all mandatory fees and charges shall be a deceptive trade practice.

SC HB601

Relative to causes of action against companies that misstate the impacts of their business on the environment.

SC A00082

Requires that all companies that sell electronic cigarettes shall annually disclose to the commissioner of health their online advertising expenditures from the previous fiscal year; makes related provisions.

SC A00147

Requires that all companies that sell electronic cigarettes shall annually disclose to the commissioner of health their online advertising expenditures from the previous fiscal year; makes related provisions.

SC S03392

Establishes the "one city act" which applies to cities with a population of one million or more and provides for an agency to disclose the personal information of individuals that would otherwise be restricted from disclosure to another agency or agent thereof for the limited purpose of providing benefits, services, or care coordination to individuals or a research study concerning the provision of benefits, services or care coordination.

SC A05916

Establishes the "one city act" which applies to cities with a population of one million or more and provides for an agency to disclose the personal information of individuals that would otherwise be restricted from disclosure to another agency or agent thereof for the limited purpose of providing benefits, services, or care coordination to individuals or a research study concerning the provision of benefits, services or care coordination.

SC SB451

In legal advertising, providing for disclosure of taxpayer-funded advertising and public notices.

SC HB3100

To amend the National Child Protection Act of 1993 to ensure that businesses and organizations that work with vulnerable populations are able to request background checks for their contractors who work with those populations, as well as for individuals that the businesses or organizations license or certify to provide care for those populations.

Similar Bills

CA SB1050

False advertising: synthetic performers.

CA AB2717

Outdoor advertising displays: arenas: exemptions.

CA SB783

Outdoor advertising displays: redevelopment agency project areas.

CA AB840

Outdoor advertising displays: redevelopment agency project areas.

HI SB2733

Relating To Liquor.

CA AB770

Advertising displays: City of Los Angeles: exemption: ordinance.

CA SB1228

Advertising displays: exemptions: redevelopment agency projects.

AZ HB2179

Marijuana; advertising; restrictions