Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB939

Introduced
10/3/23  

Caption

In rules of evidence, providing for protection of reproductive health services records.

Impact

The bill will have significant implications for the handling of reproductive health records within Pennsylvania. By enforcing stricter confidentiality standards, health care providers will need to implement additional measures to ensure compliance with the new requirements. It aims to safeguard sensitive patient information during civil actions or investigations, thus promoting secure handling of data regarding reproductive health, which is especially crucial in light of recent legal battles over reproductive rights. This change is expected to bolster confidence among patients, encouraging them to seek necessary health services without fear of personal information being disclosed.

Summary

Senate Bill 939 seeks to amend Title 42 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes by establishing protections for reproductive health services records. Specifically, the bill mandates that covered entities cannot disclose any communications or information related to reproductive health care services without explicit written consent from the patient or their authorized representative. This includes communications with healthcare professionals concerning reproductive health care, which is intended to enhance patient privacy and trust in seeking reproductive health services.

Sentiment

The general sentiment surrounding SB 939 appears to be supportive among those who advocate for reproductive rights and patient privacy, recognizing the importance of protecting sensitive medical information. Proponents of the bill argue that it aligns with the principles of confidentiality and patient autonomy, enabling individuals to make informed decisions regarding their health care without external pressures or fear of repercussions. However, there may also be concerns regarding the implementation of such protections, particularly on how they might affect ongoing investigations or court proceedings related to reproductive health issues.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding SB 939 revolve around balancing patient privacy rights with the necessary disclosures that may be required in certain legal contexts, such as child abuse cases or other investigations of wrongdoing. Some stakeholders may argue that while the intent of the bill is important, there are instances where medical records need to be accessed without patient consent for legal and safety reasons. This creates a potential tension between upholding patient confidentiality and ensuring that the legal system can access vital information needed for protecting individuals or prosecuting criminal behavior.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA SB886

In rules of evidence, providing for protection of reproductive health services records.

PA HB1640

In rules of evidence, providing for protection of reproductive health services records.

PA S2260

Secures protections for patients and providers accessing and providing reproductive health care services; establishes right of residents to reproductive health care activity that is restricted in other states.

PA A2218

Secures protections for patients and providers accessing and providing reproductive health care services; establishes right of residents to reproductive health care activity that is restricted in other states.*

PA HB1104

In rules of evidence, further providing for subpoena of records.

PA SB551

relative to legal protections for legal reproductive health care services.

PA SB987

In rules of evidence, further providing for subpoena of records.

PA SB1283

In rules of evidence, further providing for subpoena of records.

PA HB07135

An Act Concerning The Provision Of Reproductive And Gender-affirming Health Care Services To Patients.

PA HB1641

In insurance, providing for adverse actions against legal reproductive health care.

Similar Bills

CA AB950

An act to amend Sections 84502, 84503, 84504.

CA AB2520

Business records: disclosure.

PA SB806

Providing for unfair methods of competition and for enforcement and penalties.

PA HB95

Providing for disclosure of synthetic advertising content and for enforcement.

HI HB1682

Relating To The Disclosure Of Intimate Images.

HI SB2448

Relating To The Disclosure Of Intimate Images.

MN HF1430

Well disclosure certificates modified, fee established, and money appropriated.

MN SF1769

Requirements modification for well disclosures certificates