Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB7

Introduced
4/20/23  
Refer
4/20/23  
Refer
10/23/23  
Report Pass
10/24/23  
Engrossed
10/24/23  

Caption

In terms and courses of study, providing for parental control relating to instructional materials and books containing sexually explicit content.

Impact

The proposed legislation will impact state laws by requiring school entities to develop transparent policies regarding what constitutes sexually explicit content. Schools will need to identify materials and texts that contain such content and establish procedures for parental opt-in, whereby a student's access to these materials will depend on the parent's approval. This might lead to changes in how schools curate their library and instructional resources, particularly affecting the availability of certain books and educational materials deemed explicit.

Summary

Senate Bill 7 (SB7) seeks to amend the Public School Code of 1949 in Pennsylvania by establishing parental control over instructional materials and library books containing sexually explicit content. The bill mandates that school entities create and implement a public policy that allows parents or legal guardians to review and approve educational content that may be deemed inappropriate for students. The aim is to ensure that parents have a significant say in their children's exposure to material that could be considered sexually explicit.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB7 appears to be polarized. Supporters argue that the bill empowers parents, allowing them to safeguard their children from inappropriate content and maintain control over their education. They believe this increases transparency and accountability within educational institutions. Conversely, opponents express concern that the bill could limit educational resources available to students and infringe on the professional judgment of educators. Critics fear that it may suppress valuable discussions surrounding sexual health and consent that are crucial for comprehensive education.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the potential subjective interpretation of what qualifies as sexually explicit content and the process by which schools will implement the opt-in policy. There are fears that this could lead to censorship or the unjust removal of important educational materials that meet educational standards but may touch upon sensitive subjects. Additionally, the requirement for schools to hold public forums for policy input raises questions about the effectiveness of community involvement and whether it will genuinely reflect diverse perspectives within the larger school community.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA SB230

In terms and courses of study, providing for parental control relating to instructional materials and books containing sexually explicit content.

VA SB19

DOE; policies relating to instructional material that contains sexually explicit content.

VA HB1499

DOE; policies relating to instructional material that contains sexually explicit content.

PA HB860

In terms and courses of study, providing for prohibited review of curriculum, instructional materials and voluntary inquiry material in public school entities.

NJ A230

Requires DOE to develop model policies for ensuring parental notification of sexually explicit content in curriculum; requires board of education to provide parental notification of sexually explicit content in curriculum.

TX HB4298

Relating to parental controls and filters for certain explicit material on electronic devices; providing a civil penalty.

NM HB558

No Sexually Explicit Material In Schools

AZ SB1567

sexually explicit materials; government; prohibition

PA HB1565

In terms and courses of study, providing for instructions in firearm safety.

AZ SB1099

Sexually explicit materials; government; prohibition

Similar Bills

CA AB392

An act to add Chapter 22.

CA AB1705

Pornographic internet websites.

NJ A230

Requires DOE to develop model policies for ensuring parental notification of sexually explicit content in curriculum; requires board of education to provide parental notification of sexually explicit content in curriculum.

WI AB961

Warning labels for explicit content, creating an explicit content label warning surcharge, making an appropriation, and providing a penalty. (FE)

WI SB938

Warning labels for explicit content, creating an explicit content label warning surcharge, making an appropriation, and providing a penalty. (FE)

TX SB2101

Relating to the prohibition of access by minors to sexually explicit materials in municipal public library collections; providing a civil penalty.

SC H3471

Sexual exploitation of minors, morphed child pornography

WA SB5105

Revised for 1st substitute: Concerning sexually explicit depictions of minors.