New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S07190

Introduced
4/3/25  
Refer
4/3/25  

Caption

Relates to the use of electronic monitoring devices to monitor residents in assisted living residences and patients in nursing homes; requires consent from roommates to such electronic monitoring.

Summary

Bill S07190 amends the public health law to allow residents of assisted living residences and patients in nursing homes to install and operate electronic monitoring devices in their rooms at their own expense. The bill stipulates that any such installation must be done with the consent of any roommates, particularly if the device captures audio. The bill defines the parameters for what constitutes a resident's personal space and outlines the requirements for consent and notification regarding audio recording.

Impact

If enacted, this bill will significantly alter the rights of residents in assisted living and nursing home facilities by granting them the ability to monitor their living conditions through electronic devices. It will also impose new requirements on facilities regarding consent and notification, potentially affecting their operational protocols and privacy policies. The bill aims to enhance the safety and security of residents while balancing the privacy rights of roommates.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill S07190 appears to be mixed, with some stakeholders expressing support for increased monitoring as a means of ensuring resident safety, while others raise concerns about privacy implications and the potential for conflicts between roommates. The absence of recorded votes or detailed committee discussions suggests that the bill may still be under consideration and debate.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the balance between a resident's right to monitor their space and the privacy rights of roommates. Some advocates for the elderly support the bill for enhancing safety, while privacy advocates argue that it could lead to uncomfortable living situations and potential misuse of monitoring devices without proper oversight.

Companion Bills

NY A01967

Same As Relates to the use of electronic monitoring devices to monitor residents in assisted living residences and patients in nursing homes; requires consent from roommates to such electronic monitoring.

Previously Filed As

NY A01967

Relates to the use of electronic monitoring devices to monitor residents in assisted living residences and patients in nursing homes; requires consent from roommates to such electronic monitoring.

NY A805

Requires nursing homes to permit use of electronic monitoring devices at request of resident.

NY A10652

Allows a nursing home patient to install an electronic monitoring device in such patient's room

NY SB409

Assisted living facilities; electronic monitoring in resident rooms.

NY SB821

Nursing facilities; use of electronic monitoring devices in resident rooms.

NY SB661

Nursing facilities; electronic monitoring in resident rooms.

NY SF1918

Consent to electronic monitoring requirements modification

NY HB4517

ELECTRONIC MONITORING

NY SB3071

ELECTRONIC MONITORING

NY S1172

Requires certain group homes to install electronic monitoring devices in common areas, upon request and with uniform resident consent.

Similar Bills

PA HB1970

In general provisions, further providing for definitions; and, in licensing of drivers, further providing for issuance and content of driver's license and for carrying and exhibiting driver's license on demand.

CA AB1800

Portable electronics and optical products insurance.

TX SB1531

Relating to the electronic payment of ad valorem taxes; authorizing a fee.

PA SB861

In general provisions, further providing for definitions; and, in licensing of drivers, further providing for issuance and content of driver's license and for carrying and exhibiting driver's license on demand.

NJ S1336

The "Uniform Electronic Wills Act"; authorizes electronic wills.

NJ A3229

The "Uniform Electronic Wills Act"; authorizes electronic wills.

MD SB842

Electronic Smoking Devices - Seizure and Wholesaler Record-Keeping Requirements

NV AB18

Revises provisions relating to the electronic filing of certain documents. (BDR 5-469)