New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S05493

Introduced
2/21/25  
Refer
2/21/25  
Refer
1/7/26  

Caption

Proposes an amendment to require the use of paper ballots in elections.

Summary

Bill S05493 proposes an amendment to the New York State Constitution that mandates the use of paper ballots in elections, with exceptions for certain town officers as specified by law. The amendment aims to ensure the secrecy of voting and requires the identification of voters through their signatures when personal registration is mandated. Additionally, it stipulates that signatures must be collected from all individuals voting in person, regardless of their registration status, except in cases of illiteracy or physical disability.

Impact

If enacted, this amendment would significantly alter the current voting process in New York State by eliminating electronic voting machines in favor of paper ballots. This change would require updates to election laws and procedures, impacting election officials, voters, and potentially the technology used in elections. The amendment would also necessitate a review of voter identification processes to align with the new requirements.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill S05493 appears to be mixed, with proponents advocating for increased security and transparency in elections through the use of paper ballots. However, there may be concerns regarding the potential for increased costs and logistical challenges associated with transitioning from electronic voting systems to paper ballots. Discussions have highlighted the importance of maintaining voter accessibility while ensuring election integrity.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the debate over the effectiveness and security of paper ballots compared to electronic voting machines. Supporters of the bill argue that paper ballots are less susceptible to hacking and provide a tangible record of votes, while opponents may raise concerns about the efficiency of counting paper ballots and the potential for increased wait times at polling places. Additionally, there are discussions about how this amendment might affect voters with disabilities or those who are illiterate, as the bill includes provisions for these groups.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NY HB4935

Relating to requiring paper ballots in all elections

NY HB4152

Relating to the required use of hand-marked paper ballots for all elections.

NY SB2209

Relating to the required use of hand-marked paper ballots for all elections.

NY HB5147

Requiring full text of proposed Constitutional amendments be included on official ballots

NY SB121

Requiring full text of proposed constitutional amendments be included on official ballots

NY HB3120

Requiring full text of proposed Constitutional amendments be included on official ballots

NY SB514

Requiring full text of proposed Constitutional amendments be included on official ballots

NY HB2659

Requiring that all election audits and recounts be conducted using a hand count of paper ballots.

NY HB0048

AN ACT relating to elections; requiring counties to use pen and paper as the default method to mark ballots for elections in Wyoming; providing an exception; making conforming amendments; and providing for an effective date.

NY S1307

Requires use of paper ballots during conduct of election; requires use of open source voting technology; makes appropriation.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.