New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S05349

Introduced
2/20/25  
Refer
2/20/25  

Caption

Restricts insurers from demanding intrusive personal, financial and tax information from insureds as a standard practice in processing ordinary theft claims where no special circumstances warranting a demand for such information exists.

Summary

Bill S05349 aims to amend the insurance law in New York by prohibiting insurers from routinely demanding intrusive personal, financial, and tax information from insured individuals when processing ordinary theft claims. The bill specifies that such demands can only be made if there are special articulable circumstances that directly relate to the facts of the theft claim and are necessary to determine if the claim is fraudulent. This legislation seeks to protect insured individuals from unwarranted invasions of privacy during the claims process.

Impact

If enacted, this bill would significantly alter the practices of insurance companies in New York, ensuring that they cannot make blanket demands for sensitive information without just cause. It would create a legal framework that defines what constitutes an unfair claim settlement practice, thereby enhancing consumer protections and potentially leading to fewer invasive requests for personal data during the claims process. This could also lead to changes in how insurers conduct their investigations and settlements, as they would need to establish clear criteria for when such information is necessary.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill S05349 appears to be generally positive, as it addresses consumer privacy concerns and aims to prevent intrusive practices by insurers. However, there may be some apprehension from the insurance industry regarding the implications of restricting their ability to gather information that they believe is necessary for fraud prevention.

Contention

Notable points of contention may arise from the insurance industry, which could argue that the bill restricts their ability to gather essential information needed to assess the legitimacy of theft claims. Insurers may express concerns that the bill could lead to an increase in fraudulent claims, as it limits their investigative capabilities. Conversely, consumer advocacy groups are likely to support the bill, emphasizing the need for privacy protections and the prevention of unnecessary data collection.

Companion Bills

NY A01450

Same As Restricts insurers from demanding intrusive personal, financial and tax information from insureds as a standard practice in processing ordinary theft claims where no special circumstances warranting a demand for such information exists.

Previously Filed As

NY A01731

Restricts insurers from demanding intrusive personal, financial and tax information from insureds as a standard practice in processing ordinary theft claims where no special circumstances warranting a demand for such information exists.

NY A01450

Restricts insurers from demanding intrusive personal, financial and tax information from insureds as a standard practice in processing ordinary theft claims where no special circumstances warranting a demand for such information exists.

NY HF1014

Minnesota Insurance Guarantee Association board allowed to request financial information from insureds.

NY SF1758

Board of directors of the Minnesota Insurance Guarantee Association permission to request financial information from insureds

NY SB2484

Relating to availability of claims contact information for personal and commercial property and casualty insurers.

NY HB1382

Delinquent child support; require insurers to exchange claims information with MDHS for enforcement purposes.

NY S3143

Provides that automobile insurers may act as primary insurer and pursue claims against health insurers under certain circumstances.

NY S2461

Prohibits dental insurers from refusing to honor directions to pay from insured, modifying benefits to be paid. Requires providers to accept payment by virtual credit card as unfair claims practices.

NY H7113

Prohibits dental insurers from refusing to honor directions to pay from insured, modifying benefits to be paid. Requires providers to accept payment by virtual credit card as unfair claims practices.

NY S0905

Prohibits dental insurers from refusing to honor directions to pay from insured, modifying benefits to be paid. Requires providers to accept payment by virtual credit card as unfair claims practices.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.