New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S04489

Introduced
2/5/25  
Refer
2/5/25  

Caption

Creates an excise tax on the collection of consumer data by commercial data collectors.

Summary

Bill S04489 proposes the establishment of an excise tax on the collection of consumer data by commercial data collectors in New York. The tax is designed to be imposed monthly and varies based on the number of New York consumers whose data is collected. The bill defines commercial data collectors as for-profit entities that collect data on more than one million consumers in a month, and it outlines specific rates for the tax based on the number of consumers involved. Additionally, the bill includes provisions for recordkeeping, filing returns, and administrative procedures to ensure compliance.

Impact

If enacted, this bill would amend New York's tax law to introduce a new revenue stream through the taxation of consumer data collection, potentially affecting numerous commercial data collectors operating in the state. The bill aims to regulate the data collection industry and may lead to increased operational costs for companies that rely on consumer data. Furthermore, it may encourage companies to reconsider their data collection practices in light of the new tax obligations.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill S04489 appears to be mixed, with proponents arguing that it will help regulate the data collection industry and generate revenue for the state, while opponents may express concerns about the potential burden on businesses and the implications for consumer privacy. However, specific voting history and committee discussions are not available to provide a clearer picture of the overall sentiment.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the potential economic impact on commercial data collectors, particularly smaller businesses that may struggle with the tax burden. Additionally, there may be concerns regarding how the tax could affect consumer privacy and data management practices. Stakeholders in the tech and data industries may hold opposing views on the necessity and fairness of the tax.

Companion Bills

NY A01434

Same As Creates an excise tax on the collection of consumer data by commercial data collectors.

Previously Filed As

NY A01434

Creates an excise tax on the collection of consumer data by commercial data collectors.

NY S02012

Creates an excise tax on the collection of consumer data by commercial data collectors.

NY SB1280

Excise tax; extending sunset of apportionments of excise tax collections on oil and gas. Effective date. Emergency.

NY HB1026

Provide for the licensing of property data collectors and the registration of property data collection companies and to provide a penalty therefor.

NY SB569

Commercial Law - Online Data Privacy - Limits on Data Collection

NY S3180

Imposes tax on collection of consumer data in certain instances; dedicates portion of annual revenues to support 9-8-8 suicide prevention and behavioral health crisis hotline.

NY H0317

Adds to existing law to establish an excise tax on commercial wind turbines.

NY SB973

Debt collection; prohibiting certain contract with private debt collectors. Effective date.

NY SB973

Debt collection; prohibiting certain contract with private debt collectors. Effective date.

NY HB3002

Relating to requiring debt collectors to provide certain disclosures to consumers.

Similar Bills

CA AB1580

Counties: offices: consolidation.

TX HB4238

Relating to the collection of consumer debt incurred by certain individuals as a result of identity theft.

CA SB1392

Smog check: exemption: collector motor vehicles.

WA SB5127

Creating additional requirements for collector vehicle and horseless carriage license plates to improve compliance and public safety.

CA AB2091

Board of supervisors: debt collection.

TX SB850

Relating to the payment of certain ad valorem tax refunds.

TX SB1531

Relating to the electronic payment of ad valorem taxes; authorizing a fee.

LA HB1039

Provides for local sales and use tax audit procedures (EN SEE FISC NOTE LF RV See Note)