New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S04133

Introduced
2/3/25  
Refer
2/3/25  

Caption

Requires the registration of mail-in second-hand precious metals dealers with the department of state; regulates the conduct of the business thereof.

Summary

This bill creates a new Article 13-C in the General Business Law to regulate “mail-in second-hand precious metals dealers,” meaning businesses that buy gold, silver, platinum, jewelry, or similar items through the mail, internet, or telemarketing rather than through walk-in storefront sales. It requires such dealers to register with the Department of State before doing business in New York and sets out detailed transaction, identification, and recordkeeping rules. Under the bill, a dealer may not pay a seller unless the seller provides identifying information, including name, address, phone number, email if available, government-issued ID information, and a sworn statement that the seller owns the goods and that the information is true. Dealers must keep detailed records of each transaction, transmit required information to local law enforcement within 24 hours, retain records for at least two years, and provide electronic copies to law enforcement on request. Payments must be made by check or money order, and dealers must hold purchased goods for 10 calendar days before disposing of them.

Impact

The bill would add a new regulatory framework to state law governing mail-in precious metals and jewelry buyers, expanding oversight by the Department of State and law enforcement. It would impose registration, reporting, inspection, and holding-period requirements on affected businesses, while also creating criminal penalties for unregistered operation or violations of the article. It would also create felony penalties for sellers who knowingly provide false information and receive payment, depending on the amount paid.

Sentiment

Based on the bill text and available context, the measure appears to be framed as a consumer-protection and anti-theft enforcement bill, with an emphasis on traceability and law-enforcement access. There is no recorded committee debate or vote history in the provided materials, so no direct evidence of support or opposition is available. The structure of the bill suggests a generally enforcement-oriented approach rather than a controversial policy shift, but it would likely be viewed favorably by law enforcement and regulators and more cautiously by mail-order precious metals businesses.

Contention

The main points of contention are likely to be the compliance burden on mail-in dealers and the breadth of law-enforcement access to business records and premises. Businesses affected by the bill may object to registration requirements, mandatory identification collection, 24-hour reporting, a 10-day holding period, and the use of felony penalties for regulatory violations. On the other hand, supporters would likely argue that these requirements are necessary to deter theft, fencing, and fraud in a market that can be difficult to monitor because transactions occur remotely rather than in person.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NY H1345

Statewide Data Sharing of Secondhand Dealer, Secondary Metals Recycler, and Pawnbroker Transactions

NY HB1191

Secondhand Precious Metal Object Dealers - Temporary Event-Based Dealer Limited License - Establishment

NY HB97

Precious metals dealers; permit requirements.

NY S1582

Statewide Data Sharing of Secondhand Dealer and Pawnbroker Transactions

NY AB2633

An act to amend Sections 21625, 21626, 21627, 21628, 21630, 21631, 21636, 21636.1, 21636.5, 21637, and 21638 of, and to repeal Section 21634 of, the Business and Professions Code, relating to secondhand dealers.

NY HB97

A BILL to amend and reenact § 54.1-4108 of the Code of Virginia, relating to professions and occupations; precious metals dealers; permit requirements.

NY HB2706

Relating to businesses regulated by the Department of Transportation.

NY A353

Requires Secretary of State and Chief Administrator of MVC to conduct audit of certain voter registrations and annual audits thereafter; requires proof of citizenship for voter registration at MVC.

NY S2944

Requires businesses that conduct business to register and maintain required filings with the secretary of state so that consumers and small businesses may readily identify responsible parties, verify good standing, and effectuate service of process.

NY H7844

Requires businesses that conduct business to register and maintain required filings with the secretary of state so that consumers and small businesses may readily identify responsible parties, verify good standing, and effectuate service of process.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.