New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S02404

Introduced
1/17/25  
Refer
1/17/25  

Caption

Requires police officers to report the misconduct of a police officer; requires the division of criminal justice to establish a protocol to be followed by police agencies when handling and recording mandatory reports of misconduct by a police officer; establishes the crime of failure to report misconduct by a police officer.

Summary

Bill S02404 mandates that police officers in New York must report any misconduct they observe among their colleagues, specifically in cases of excessive force. The bill establishes a detailed protocol for police agencies to follow when handling and recording these reports, which includes protections against retaliation for officers who report misconduct. It also introduces a new crime, classified as a class D felony, for officers who fail to report such misconduct, thereby emphasizing accountability within law enforcement agencies.

Impact

The bill significantly alters the landscape of police accountability in New York by instituting mandatory reporting requirements for police officers. This change aims to foster a culture of transparency and responsibility within police departments, potentially leading to a decrease in incidents of misconduct. The introduction of penalties for failing to report misconduct may also encourage officers to adhere to the new standards, impacting internal police department policies and procedures.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill S02404 appears to be mixed, with some supporting the increased accountability and transparency it aims to enforce, while others express concerns about the implications for police morale and the potential for misuse of the reporting requirements. Discussions indicate a recognition of the need for reform in law enforcement practices, but also highlight fears regarding the practical implementation of the bill.

Contention

Notable points of contention include concerns from law enforcement representatives about the potential for false reporting and the impact on officer relationships within departments. Critics argue that the bill could create a culture of distrust among officers, while supporters assert that it is a necessary step toward greater accountability and public trust in law enforcement.

Companion Bills

NY A01047

Same As Requires police officers to report the misconduct of a police officer; requires the division of criminal justice to establish a protocol to be followed by police agencies when handling and recording mandatory reports of misconduct by a police officer; establishes the crime of failure to report misconduct by a police officer.

Previously Filed As

NY S00743

Requires police officers to report the misconduct of a police officer; requires the division of criminal justice to establish a protocol to be followed by police agencies when handling and recording mandatory reports of misconduct by a police officer; establishes the crime of failure to report misconduct by a police officer.

NY A01047

Requires police officers to report the misconduct of a police officer; requires the division of criminal justice to establish a protocol to be followed by police agencies when handling and recording mandatory reports of misconduct by a police officer; establishes the crime of failure to report misconduct by a police officer.

NY HB2923

REPORTING POLICE MISCONDUCT

NY S3033

Requires online portal to report law enforcement officer misconduct; establishes duty to report by law enforcement officers.

NY A1707

Requires online portal to report law enforcement officer misconduct; establishes duty to report by law enforcement officers.

NY A5007

Requires establishment of hotline for purpose of reporting certain acts of misconduct by public officials.

NY HB1593

Criminal procedures; authorizing peace officers to dispute reports of misconduct; codification; effective date.

NY HB1593

Criminal procedures; authorizing peace officers to dispute reports of misconduct; codification; effective date.

NY LD1784

An Act to Require Police Departments to Publish and Make Accessible Their Policies and Procedures and Require Training of Officers

NY S03095

Relates to establishing reporting duties of law enforcement agencies with respect to police misconduct allegations and outcomes; requires the division of criminal justice services to establish and maintain on its official website a public, searchable database of alleged infractions and police misconduct complaints.

Similar Bills

MI SB0343

Law enforcement: other; individuals filing complaints against law enforcement; allow to remain private. Creates new act.

TX SB571

Relating to the reporting and investigation of certain misconduct and child abuse and neglect; creating a criminal offense.

DC B26-0029

Institution of Higher Education Sexual Misconduct Reporting and Resource Accessibility Act of 2025

PA HB1279

In sexual violence, dating violence, domestic violence and stalking education, prevention and respo nse at institutions of higher education and private licensed schools, further providing for scope of article, for definitions, for education program and for follow-up and providing for staff training and for enforcement and penalties; in postsecondary institution sexual harassment and sexual violence policy and online reporting system, further providing for definitions, for policy for postsecondary institution sexual harassment and sexual violence and for online reporting system, providing for sexual misconduct climate surveys, establishing the Task Force on Postsecondary Sexual Misconduct and providing for confidential resource advisors, for waivers for student victims, for data reporting requirements and for enforcement and penalties; and making editorial changes.

NJ A4241

Requires police misconduct training course be included in police basic training curriculum.

CA AB1388

Law enforcement: settlement agreements.

TX SB1573

Relating to a limitation on the use of certain unsubstantiated information relating to peace officer misconduct.

NJ S2442

Requires institutions of higher education to review employment history of prospective employees who will have regular contact with students to ascertain allegations of child abuse or sexual misconduct.