Prohibits residential landlords from charging tenants with fees for the payment of rent through an automated clearing house or online payment system.
Summary
Bill S00947 seeks to amend the New York real property law to prohibit residential landlords from charging tenants fees for using automated clearing house (ACH) or online payment systems for rent payments. The bill ensures that landlords cannot require tenants to use electronic payment methods exclusively and mandates that landlords provide alternative payment methods that do not incur fees, such as cash or personal checks. Additionally, any agreement that waives these rights by tenants would be considered void, reinforcing tenant protections against unfair fees.
Impact
If enacted, this bill would significantly alter the landscape of rental payment practices in New York. It would prevent landlords from imposing additional costs on tenants for using electronic payment options, thereby promoting more equitable access to payment methods. This change could lead to a decrease in the prevalence of electronic payment systems that charge fees, potentially benefiting low-income tenants who may struggle with such costs. The bill would also reinforce tenant rights by invalidating any agreements that attempt to waive these protections.
Sentiment
The sentiment surrounding Bill S00947 appears to be largely supportive, as indicated by the voting history. The bill passed through the Senate Judiciary Committee with a strong majority and received favorable votes during subsequent Senate and Assembly floor votes. The discussions suggest a recognition of the need for tenant protections in the context of modern payment systems, although there may be some opposition from landlords concerned about the implications for their operational costs.
Contention
Notable points of contention include concerns from some landlord associations regarding the potential financial impact of prohibiting fees associated with electronic payments. Landlords argue that these fees help cover the costs of processing payments and that eliminating them could lead to increased rent or reduced services. Conversely, tenant advocacy groups support the bill, emphasizing the need to protect tenants from unnecessary fees and promote fair access to payment methods.
Same As
Prohibits residential landlords from charging tenants with fees for the payment of rent through an automated clearing house or online payment system.
An Act Prohibiting The Eviction Of A Residential Tenant For Nonpayment Of Rent If The Landlord's Online Rental Payment System Prevents Such Payment Of Rent.
An Act Prohibiting The Eviction Of A Residential Tenant For Nonpayment Of Rent If The Landlord's Online Rental Payment System Prevents Such Payment Of Rent.