New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Assembly Bill A11557

Caption

Relates to the form of submission and abstract for proposed amendments to the constitution

Summary

This bill amends the Election Law to change how proposed constitutional amendments are presented to voters. It allows the Legislature to determine the form of submission and the abstract for a proposed constitutional amendment either in the same concurrent resolution that submits the amendment or in a separate concurrent resolution adopted by both houses at least 120 days before the general election. The bill also directs the Legislature to use best efforts to make the submission and abstract comply with plain-language requirements and to aim for an eighth-grade reading level or lower, as measured by the Automated Readability Index or a comparable tool, while making clear that no specific score is mandatory. The measure further provides that once the form of submission and abstract are set, the State Board of Elections must transmit them without amendment or alteration, except for assigning the ballot order number. It applies immediately to constitutional amendments that receive first passage during the 2025-2026 legislative session and to later amendments, but it excludes amendments that already achieved first passage during the 2023-2024 session.

Impact

The bill would amend section 4-108 of the Election Law and affect the process used to place constitutional amendments before voters. It shifts some procedural authority to the Legislature by expressly allowing it to set the ballot abstract and submission language in advance, while also imposing a plain-language and readability preference for those materials. The State Board of Elections would retain a ministerial role in transmitting the language and assigning ballot order, but would not be able to alter the approved text.

Sentiment

Based on the bill text and available context, the bill appears procedural and noncontroversial in nature, with an emphasis on clearer voter-facing language and standardized handling of constitutional amendment abstracts. There is no recorded committee transcript or vote history in the provided materials, so no direct evidence of opposition or support is available. The overall framing suggests a reform intended to improve readability and consistency rather than to change substantive policy outcomes.

Contention

The main potential point of contention is the balance between legislative control over ballot language and the role of the State Board of Elections. The bill gives the Legislature authority to fix the form of submission and abstract, which could raise concerns about political influence over how amendments are described to voters. Another possible issue is the use of a readability target without a mandatory score: supporters may view this as a practical plain-language standard, while critics could see it as too vague to ensure meaningful voter comprehension.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NY SB262

AN ACT proposing an amendment to Section 256 of the Constitution of Kentucky relating to the submission of constitutional amendments to voters.

NY HB2

Changes the election date for the spring 2026 statewide election for the submission of proposed constitutional amendments (Item #1) (EG NO IMPACT See Note)

NY HJR46

Proposing a constitutional amendment changing the vote requirement in the legislature to approve a proposed constitutional amendment for submission to the voters of this state to two-thirds of the members present in each chamber of the legislature.

NY SB2

Changes election dates for the spring 2026 statewide election for submission of proposed constitutional amendments. (Item #1) (gov sig) (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

NY HJR173

Proposes a constitutional amendment relating to taxation

NY HJR174

Proposes a constitutional amendment relating to taxation

NY SJR30

Modifies process for proposing and approving constitutional amendments

NY SCR60

Proposes constitutional amendment to provide for Statewide initiative and referendum.

NY HJR131

Proposes a constitutional amendment relating to taxation

NY HJR21

Proposing an amendment to the Oregon Constitution relating to processes for amending the Oregon Constitution.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.