Provides a one-year utility bill tax and surcharge holiday and two-year green energy tax holiday
Summary
A10938 would create two temporary tax relief measures related to energy costs. First, it establishes a one-year “utility bill tax and surcharge holiday” beginning 14 days after the bill takes effect, during which utility customers would be exempt from the gross receipts tax, sales tax, and several utility-related surcharges, including the system benefits charge, temporary state assessment/incremental state assessment charge, and renewable portfolio standard charge. Utility companies would be required to reduce customer bills by the amount of those exempt taxes and surcharges.
Second, the bill creates a two-year “green energy tax holiday” that would prohibit tariffs or surcharges on utility ratepayers for the construction or implementation of renewable energy systems, electric vehicle ready infrastructure, and electric vehicle charging stations. The measure also directs the state comptroller, in consultation with the Division of the Budget, to transfer money from the general fund to replace revenue that would otherwise have been deposited during the utility tax holiday period. The bill takes effect immediately.
Impact
The bill would amend the Tax Law and State Finance Law by adding new sections 47-a, 47-b, and 89-l. It would temporarily suspend certain state taxes and utility-related charges on customer bills, require corresponding price reductions by utility companies, and shift the fiscal burden to the general fund to offset lost revenue. It would also limit the ability to impose certain tariffs and surcharges related to renewable energy and electric vehicle infrastructure for two years, affecting utilities, ratepayers, and state revenue accounts tied to energy programs.
Sentiment
The available record shows the bill was introduced and referred to the Assembly Committee on Ways and Means, but there are no recorded committee transcripts or votes in the provided materials. Based on the bill’s caption and structure, it appears intended as consumer and ratepayer relief, particularly for utility customers facing energy-related charges, while also promoting renewable energy and EV infrastructure by temporarily suspending related surcharges. Because no debate or vote history is provided, there is no documented formal support or opposition in the record here.
Contention
The main likely point of contention is fiscal impact: the bill would reduce utility-related tax and surcharge collections and require a transfer from the general fund to make up for the lost revenue. That could draw concern from budget officials and lawmakers focused on state finances. Another potential issue is policy scope, since the bill not only relieves utility customers of taxes and surcharges but also blocks certain renewable-energy and EV-related tariffs for two years, which could be viewed either as helpful consumer relief or as interference with existing clean-energy funding mechanisms. No specific objections or supporters are identified in the provided materials.
Relates to the department of public service; limits increases in the amount of surcharges; establishes a one year moratorium on the collection of energy surcharges; establishes a moratorium on new surcharge assessments, taxes or fees.
Allows surplus or uncommitted funds in the New York state climate investment account to be returned to ratepayers; establishes a one-year utility bill tax and surcharge holiday and a two-year green energy tax holiday; relates to audits of utility corporations; authorizes the public service commission to reconsider rate increases; grants customers the right to decline smart meters and prohibits such customers from being penalized or charged exercising such right; directs the public service commission to conduct a study analyzing the economic impact of the use of smart meters; relates to costs and expenses of the department of public service and the public service commission; directs the public service commission to develop a formula to determine the average cost to comply with the provisions set forth in article seventy-five of the environmental conservation law; provides for a ratepayer protection tax credit; repeals certain provisions of law relating to the assessment of costs and expenses of the department of public service and the public service commission.