Relates to establishing civil penalties for failure of propane providers to deliver emergency service under automatic refill contracts
Summary
This bill would add a new section to the Public Service Law creating civil penalties for propane companies that fail to provide emergency delivery service to customers covered by automatic refill contracts. A violation occurs when a propane provider does not deliver propane within 24 hours after being notified of, or identifying, an emergency condition such as an out-of-fuel event or an imminent interruption of heat or other essential service, so long as the customer is within the company’s designated service area.
The Department of Public Service would be responsible for receiving, investigating, and adjudicating complaints, and it would be authorized to adopt implementing regulations, hold administrative hearings, and assess penalties of up to $10,000 per violation. The Attorney General could also investigate, bring civil actions to recover penalties, and seek injunctive relief, restitution, and other available remedies. Each missed emergency delivery would count as a separate violation, even if multiple failures involve the same customer or occur in the same heating season or contract period.
Impact
The bill would expand state regulatory oversight of propane service by creating a specific enforcement mechanism for emergency delivery failures under automatic refill contracts. It would add new authority for the Department of Public Service and the Attorney General, establish a civil penalty framework, and direct all recovered penalties to the state general fund. The measure would not eliminate existing consumer protection or utility-law remedies, but would supplement them with a targeted penalty and complaint process for propane service disruptions.
Sentiment
The available record shows the bill was introduced and referred to the Assembly Committee on Corporations, Authorities and Commissions, with no recorded votes or committee transcript available. Based on the text, the bill appears to be consumer-protection oriented and aimed at ensuring reliable heat and fuel delivery during emergencies, suggesting a generally favorable policy posture toward affected customers. Because no discussion or vote history is provided, there is no documented opposition or support from legislators in the available materials.
Contention
The main policy tension is between consumer protection and the burden placed on propane providers. Supporters would likely emphasize the need for timely emergency delivery to prevent loss of heat, health risks, and property damage, especially for customers relying on automatic refill arrangements. Potential concerns for industry stakeholders include the 24-hour delivery requirement, the possibility of multiple penalties for repeated failures, and the size of the fines, which could be imposed even when service disruptions occur during the same season or contract period. The bill also gives the Department broad discretion to determine penalty amounts and enforce compliance, which could be a point of concern for regulated entities.
Establishes civil penalties for a propane company's improper denial of propane service to consumers located in such propane company's designated service territory; provides for enforcement of such penalties by the department of public service and the office of the attorney general; directs that such civil penalties be deposited into the New York state general fund.
A bill for an act relating to the advertised and delivered speeds of broadband services provided by communication service providers, and providing civil penalties.
Providing for plumber and plumbing contractors licensure; establishing the State Board of Plumbing Contractors and providing for its powers and duties; conferring powers and imposing duties on the Department of State; establishing fees, fines and civil penalties; establishing the Plumbing Contractors Licensure Account; and making an appropriation.
Providing for plumber and plumbing contractors licensure; establishing the State Board of Plumbing Contractors and providing for its powers and duties; conferring powers and imposing duties on the Department of State; establishing fees, fines and civil penalties; establishing the Plumbing Contractors Licensure Account; and making an appropriation.
A bill for an act relating to licensing of service companies, motor vehicle service contracts, and residential service contracts, and providing civil penalties.(Formerly SSB 3057; See SF 2505.)
A bill for an act relating to licensing of service companies, motor vehicle service contracts, and residential service contracts, and providing civil penalties.(Formerly HSB 517; See HF 2756.)
A bill for an act relating to licensing of service companies, motor vehicle service contracts, and residential service contracts, and providing civil penalties.(See HF 2714, HF 2756.)
A bill for an act relating to licensing of service companies, motor vehicle service contracts, and residential service contracts, and providing civil penalties.(See SF 2445, SF 2505.)