Makes the crimes of menacing and stalking bail eligible.
Summary
A07327 amends New York’s criminal procedure law to make certain menacing and stalking offenses bail-eligible. Specifically, it adds crimes involving menacing and stalking to the list of qualifying offenses that can support pretrial detention or bail determinations under the state’s bail statutes. The bill also updates related provisions governing criminal contempt where the protected party is the victim of an alleged menacing or stalking offense, aligning those contempt provisions with the new bail-eligibility categories.
In practical terms, the bill expands the set of offenses for which a court may set bail or remand a defendant, including menacing in the first, second, or third degree and stalking in the first through fourth degrees. It makes parallel changes to both the general bail statute and the family court/order-of-protection-related bail provisions, and it takes effect immediately upon enactment.
Impact
The bill would amend sections 510.10 and 530.40 of the Criminal Procedure Law, which govern bail eligibility in criminal cases and in cases involving family offense or protective-order contexts. By adding menacing and stalking to the qualifying-offense lists, it broadens judicial authority to impose bail or remand in those cases, affecting defendants charged with those offenses and potentially increasing pretrial detention exposure. It also revises criminal contempt provisions so that violations of orders of protection tied to alleged menacing or stalking victims are treated consistently within the bail framework.
Sentiment
The available voting history suggests the bill received some support but was not advanced out of committee, as the Assembly Codes Committee vote was 14 yeas and 6 nays with the measure held for consideration. The caption and structure indicate the bill is framed as a public-safety measure, and its sponsor appears to be seeking to close a perceived gap in the current bail-eligibility scheme. At the same time, the committee result implies there was enough hesitation or disagreement to prevent immediate movement, consistent with the broader sensitivity around expanding bail eligibility in New York.
Contention
The main point of contention is likely whether menacing and stalking should be treated as bail-eligible offenses, which would expand pretrial detention authority beyond the current framework. Supporters would view the change as necessary to protect victims and address repeat or escalating threatening conduct, especially where protective orders are involved. Opponents may be concerned that the bill further broadens bail eligibility and could lead to more pretrial detention for offenses that may not always involve physical injury, raising due-process and criminal-justice-reform concerns. The committee vote indicates the issue was divisive, though no transcript remarks are available to identify specific arguments or members.
Payment rates established for certain substance use disorder treatment services, and vendor eligibility recodified for payments from the behavioral health fund.