New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Assembly Bill A06684

Introduced
3/7/25  
Refer
3/7/25  

Caption

Permits at the discretion of the court certain members of the deceased victim's family to read statements in court during the sentencing of a defendant, rather than allowing only a single member of the victim's family to read a statement in court, upon consultation with counsel for the defendant and the people.

Summary

Bill A06684 amends the criminal procedure law to allow certain family members of a deceased victim to read statements in court during the sentencing of a defendant. This change permits the court to exercise discretion in allowing either a spouse or parent of the deceased victim, or both, to present statements, rather than limiting this opportunity to a single family member. The bill aims to provide a more inclusive platform for family members to express their sentiments and experiences related to the victim during sentencing hearings.

Impact

If enacted, this bill would modify existing criminal procedure laws in New York, specifically section 380.50, to enhance the rights of family members of deceased victims. It would allow for a broader representation of the victim's family in court, potentially impacting the emotional weight of victim impact statements during sentencing. This change could lead to more nuanced considerations by the court regarding the impact of the crime on the victim's family.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill A06684 appears to be cautiously supportive, as indicated by the voting outcome in the Assembly Codes Committee, where it received 16 votes in favor and 6 against. However, the bill was held for further consideration, suggesting that while there is some support, there may be concerns that require further discussion or amendment before it can proceed.

Contention

Notable points of contention may arise regarding the discretion granted to the court in determining which family members may speak. Some may argue that this discretion could lead to inconsistencies in how victim statements are handled, while others may express concern over the emotional impact on the court proceedings. The balance between allowing family members to voice their experiences and maintaining the integrity of the court process is likely to be a key area of debate.

Companion Bills

NY S00390

Same As Permits at the discretion of the court certain members of the deceased victim's family to read statements in court during the sentencing of a defendant, rather than allowing only a single member of the victim's family to read a statement in court, upon consultation with counsel for the defendant and the people.

Previously Filed As

NY S00390

Permits at the discretion of the court certain members of the deceased victim's family to read statements in court during the sentencing of a defendant, rather than allowing only a single member of the victim's family to read a statement in court, upon consultation with counsel for the defendant and the people.

NY S00611

Provides for victim statements, or statements from anyone designated by a victim to speak, at the sentencing of a defendant for certain misdemeanors.

NY S0145

Requires the courts to consider the parental status of the defendant at the time of sentencing and allows the defendant to present a family impact statement, including testimony, videos and documents relative to their parental status.

NY S2162

Requires the courts to consider the parental status of the defendant at the time of sentencing and allows the defendant to present a family impact statement, including testimony, videos and documents relative to their parental status.

NY S05586

Provides for family members of a crime victim and interested parties to make statements to members of the parole board; provides that such oral statement shall be made to the members of the state board of parole who will determine whether the defendant is released.

NY A02138

Provides for victim statements, or statements from anyone designated by a victim to speak, at the sentencing of a defendant for certain misdemeanors.

NY SB26112

Concerning defendants who fail to appear in court, and, in connection therewith, permitting certain conditions on pretrial release for defendants who have previously failed to appear.

NY A3520

Establishes new mitigating factor, reduced sentencing, and resentencing for certain defendants who are victims of abuse.

NY S2878

Establishes new mitigating factor, reduced sentencing, and resentencing for certain defendants who are victims of abuse.

NY S06656

Provides for electronic court appearance in a criminal action, anywhere in the state, at the discretion of the court having jurisdiction of the defendant; provides that the defendant must, after consultation with counsel, consent on the record; provides that the chief administrator of the courts must first approve the use of such electronic appearance.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.