New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Assembly Bill A05870

Introduced
2/24/25  
Refer
2/24/25  

Caption

Enacts the "television subscriber choice act" to enhance consumer choice and ensure that multichannel video programming distributors have the flexibility to offer programming packages that best meet the needs and preferences of their subscribers; requires that a video programmer shall offer each channel for license to a multichannel video programming distributor without requiring channel bundling requirements as a condition of carriage of such channel; makes it unlawful for a video programmer to demand unreasonable fees or other financial obligations for channel carriage; defines terms; makes related provisions.

Summary

Bill A05870, known as the "television subscriber choice act," aims to amend the general obligations law to enhance consumer choice in the video programming market. It seeks to eliminate practices such as channel bundling and minimum penetration provisions that restrict multichannel video programming distributors (MVPDs) from offering flexible programming packages. By requiring video programmers to offer channels without bundling and prohibiting unreasonable fees, the bill intends to foster a more competitive and consumer-friendly video distribution market.

Impact

The bill will significantly impact the agreements between multichannel video programming distributors and video programmers by prohibiting certain restrictive practices. It will amend existing laws to ensure that MVPDs can negotiate more favorable terms that align with consumer preferences, potentially leading to lower costs and increased access to diverse programming options. This change is expected to reshape the landscape of video programming distribution in New York State.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding Bill A05870 appears to be generally positive, as it addresses consumer concerns regarding limited choices and high costs associated with current video programming agreements. However, there may be some opposition from video programmers who benefit from the existing bundling practices and may view the bill as a threat to their revenue models.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the potential pushback from video programmers who may argue that bundling and minimum penetration provisions are necessary for their business models. Additionally, concerns may arise regarding the impact of the bill on the revenue streams of smaller video programmers who rely on these practices to maintain profitability. The debate may center around balancing consumer choice with the financial viability of content providers.

Companion Bills

NY S04653

Same As Enacts the "television subscriber choice act" to enhance consumer choice and ensure that multichannel video programming distributors have the flexibility to offer programming packages that best meet the needs and preferences of their subscribers; requires that a video programmer shall offer each channel for license to a multichannel video programming distributor without requiring channel bundling requirements as a condition of carriage of such channel; makes it unlawful for a video programmer to demand unreasonable fees or other financial obligations for channel carriage; defines terms; makes related provisions.

Previously Filed As

NY S04653

Enacts the "television subscriber choice act" to enhance consumer choice and ensure that multichannel video programming distributors have the flexibility to offer programming packages that best meet the needs and preferences of their subscribers; requires that a video programmer shall offer each channel for license to a multichannel video programming distributor without requiring channel bundling requirements as a condition of carriage of such channel; makes it unlawful for a video programmer to demand unreasonable fees or other financial obligations for channel carriage; defines terms; makes related provisions.

NY S00733

Enacts the Multichannel Video Programming Distributor Competition Act; defines terms; imposes a 5% excise on gross receipts.

SD HB1116

Prohibit a video streaming service from transmitting certain advertising during children's programming and provide a penalty therefor.

US SB328

Stop Sports Blackouts ActThis bill requires cable and satellite broadcast providers to issue rebates to customers who are denied access to video programming included in their subscription because of programming negotiations. Specifically, where a provider’s negotiations related to the retransmission or carriage of video programming result in the provider failing to offer access to programming included in a customer’s subscription, the customer must be issued a rebate for the affected period. The Federal Communications Commission is directed to issue rules to this effect, including to establish the appropriate amount for such a rebate.  

US HB9067

To amend the Communications Act of 1934 to provide for a gender identity content descriptor for video programming, and for other purposes.

NJ A4887

Provides televisions in State buildings shall display closed captioning for programming.

NJ S3237

Provides televisions in State buildings shall display closed captioning for programming.

MN SF2289

Community cable television programming appropriation

MA S2556

To modernize funding for community media programming

MA H91

To modernize funding for community media programming

Similar Bills

US HB2230

Independent Programmers Tax Incentive Act

CA SB576

Video streaming services: commercial advertisements.

MA H3119

Relative to taxation of equipment used to provide broadband communication services

MA S1996

Relative to taxation of equipment used to provide broadband communication services

CA SB96

Streaming services: commercial advertisements.

KS HB2670

Prohibiting video streaming services from transmitting commercial advertisements with the audio louder than that of the main video streaming content in which such advertisement is placed.

CT SB00232

An Act Concerning Streaming Video Services And The Volume Of Commercial Advertisements.

IA SF2294

A bill for an act relating to the audio volume of commercial advertisements provided by a video streaming service, and providing penalties.(Formerly SSB 3012.)