Bill A05131 proposes to amend the county law in New York to abolish the office of coroner in all counties except Lewis and Madison counties. The bill allows county boards of supervisors to enact a local law to abolish the coroner's office and establish the position of medical examiner instead. This transition would require a permissive referendum and would lead to the expiration of current coroners' terms upon the appointment of a new medical examiner.
Impact
If enacted, this bill would significantly alter the structure of death investigation in New York counties by replacing coroners with medical examiners. This change could lead to more standardized practices in forensic investigations and potentially improve the quality of death investigations across the state. The bill specifically excludes Lewis and Madison counties, which may continue to operate under the existing coroner system, thus creating a disparity in how death investigations are handled in different counties.
Sentiment
The sentiment surrounding Bill A05131 appears to be mixed. Supporters argue that the move towards medical examiners will enhance the professionalism and reliability of death investigations. However, there may be concerns from current coroners and their supporters about job security and the implications of such a transition.
Contention
Notable points of contention include the potential job loss for current coroners and the differing opinions on the effectiveness of coroners versus medical examiners. Supporters of the bill emphasize improved forensic standards, while opponents may argue for the value of the coroner system and the local knowledge that coroners bring to their communities.
Reestablishes the office of coroner in the county of Oswego; removes the powers and duties of coroners from the district attorney in such county; allows Oswego County to appoint a coroner.