New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Assembly Bill A04214

Introduced
1/31/25  
Refer
1/31/25  

Caption

Permits a violation captured by a speed camera to be dismissed upon the application of the person alleged to be liable for such violation if any information that is required to be inserted in the notice of liability is omitted from such notice of liability, misdescribed or illegible.

Summary

Bill A04214 amends the vehicle and traffic law to enhance the requirements for notices of liability issued for speed camera violations. Specifically, it mandates that a notice must include essential information such as the name and address of the alleged violator, vehicle registration number, violation location, date and time, camera identification number, and at least two date and time-stamped images of the vehicle. If any of this required information is omitted, misdescribed, or illegible, the bill allows for the dismissal of the violation upon application by the alleged violator.

Impact

The bill's impact on state laws includes a stricter standard for the documentation and evidence required in speed camera violation notices. This change aims to protect individuals from being unfairly penalized due to clerical errors or omissions in the notice, thereby potentially reducing the number of contested violations and appeals. It may also lead to a reevaluation of how speed camera systems operate and the accuracy of the data collected.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around Bill A04214 appears to be cautious, with discussions likely focusing on the balance between enforcing traffic laws and ensuring fairness for vehicle owners. While some may support the bill for its consumer protection aspects, others may express concern about its implications for traffic safety and enforcement efficacy.

Contention

Notable points of contention may arise from differing views on the effectiveness of speed cameras in reducing traffic violations and accidents. Proponents of the bill may argue that it safeguards the rights of vehicle owners, while opponents might contend that it could undermine the deterrent effect of speed cameras and lead to increased violations if enforcement is perceived as less stringent.

Companion Bills

NY S07085

Same As Permits a violation captured by a speed camera to be dismissed upon the application of the person alleged to be liable for such violation if any information that is required to be inserted in the notice of liability is omitted from such notice of liability, misdescribed or illegible.

Previously Filed As

NY S07085

Permits a violation captured by a speed camera to be dismissed upon the application of the person alleged to be liable for such violation if any information that is required to be inserted in the notice of liability is omitted from such notice of liability, misdescribed or illegible.

NY S08410

Relates to notices of violation returnable to a parking violations bureau in a city with a population of one million or more; provides that in a city with a population of one million persons or more, if such notice is served upon the operator of a vehicle that has no such registration plate or if such registration plate is concealed or obscured, the vehicle identification number may be inserted in such notice in place of the plate designation and plate type.

NY S2912

Amends the definition of abandoned property by imposing the requirement that the building owner be notified of the violation and has failed to address such violations in the timeframes set forth in the notice of violation or court order.

NY A10104

Requires notices of liability issued for nonpayment of tolls to be uniform in form and content and contain information on monetary penalties, the public authority issuing the notice of liability and the rates, fees, or charges applicable to nonpayment of tolls.

NY S09178

Requires notices of liability issued for nonpayment of tolls to be uniform in form and content and contain information on monetary penalties, the public authority issuing the notice of liability and the rates, fees, or charges applicable to nonpayment of tolls.

NY S0804

Extends the repayment period for toll violations, and requires the RI transit and bridge authority to notify frequent violators by certified mail that their driver's license may be in jeopardy for failure to pay toll violations.

NY H5272

Allows the owner of a rented or leased motor vehicle to establish non-liability for traffic violations.

NY S09527

Relates to adjudications and owner liability for a violation of traffic-control signal indications in the city of Ithaca.

NY A10455

Relates to adjudications and owner liability for a violation of traffic-control signal indications in the city of Ithaca.

NY S08120

Relates to owner liability for failure of operators to comply with toll collection regulations; requires public authorities to send a notice to owners upon incurring an obligation to pay a toll; provides for the adjudication of such liability and defenses to an allegation of liability; repeals certain provisions of law relating thereto.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.