New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Assembly Bill A00524

Introduced
1/8/25  
Refer
1/8/25  

Caption

Provides that FOIL appeals are to be heard by the committee on open government.

Summary

Bill A00524 proposes amendments to the public officers law concerning the handling of Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) appeals. Specifically, it mandates that appeals from individuals denied access to records must be directed to the committee on open government rather than the head or governing body of the agency involved. The committee is required to respond to these appeals within ten business days, providing either access to the requested records or a written explanation for the denial. Additionally, the bill stipulates that the committee bears the burden of proof in cases where access to records is denied, and it allows for the recovery of attorney's fees for individuals who prevail in such appeals. The bill aims to streamline the appeals process for FOIL requests, making it more accessible and efficient for the public. By centralizing the appeals process under the committee on open government, the legislation seeks to enhance transparency and accountability in government operations. The proposed changes are intended to reduce delays and improve compliance with FOIL, thereby fostering a more open government environment. In terms of impact, the bill modifies existing statutes related to public access to government records, potentially increasing the volume of appeals handled by the committee on open government. This shift could lead to a greater emphasis on the committee's role in ensuring compliance with FOIL, which may require additional resources or adjustments in their operational procedures. Moreover, the bill's provisions for awarding attorney's fees could incentivize individuals to pursue appeals, thereby increasing public engagement in government transparency issues. The sentiment surrounding the bill appears to be generally supportive, as it aligns with ongoing efforts to enhance government transparency and public access to information. However, there may be concerns regarding the capacity of the committee on open government to handle an increased workload effectively. Notable points of contention may arise from agencies that could view this shift as a reduction of their authority in handling FOIL requests, as well as potential debates over the implications for governmental efficiency and resource allocation.

Impact

The bill significantly alters the process for handling FOIL appeals by transferring the responsibility from individual agencies to the committee on open government. This change is expected to enhance public access to information and streamline the appeals process, but it may also place additional demands on the committee's resources. The requirement for the committee to prove the validity of record denials could lead to more successful appeals, thereby increasing public engagement in transparency efforts. Overall, the bill aims to strengthen the framework for public access to government records.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around Bill A00524 is positive, reflecting a growing emphasis on government transparency and accountability. Supporters argue that the bill will simplify the appeals process and empower citizens in their right to access public records. However, there are concerns about the potential strain on the committee on open government's resources and its ability to manage an increased volume of appeals effectively.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the potential pushback from government agencies that may feel their authority is being undermined by the new requirement to direct appeals to the committee on open government. Some agencies may express concerns about the implications for their operational efficiency and the additional burden of complying with the new requirements. Additionally, discussions may arise regarding the adequacy of resources allocated to the committee to handle the expected increase in appeals.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NY S09607

Requires agencies subject to FOIL requirements to promulgate rules and regulations regarding to whom a requestor may appeal a denial and how to request records from or appeal a denial; makes certain provisions relating to publication of contact information for FOIL requests and appeals.

NY A11143

Requires agencies subject to FOIL requirements to promulgate rules and regulations regarding to whom a requestor may appeal a denial and how to request records from or appeal a denial; makes certain provisions relating to publication of contact information for FOIL requests and appeals.

NY SB496

Advanced Clean Fleets Regulation: appeals advisory committee: exemptions.

NY S09739

Requires all agencies to submit to the committee on open government a log of all freedom of information law requests for each year in which they received or have pending a request for records; requires the committee on open government to publish, on one webpage, all freedom of information law request logs it receives.

NY A06487

Expands the training time for local municipalities in relation to the open meetings law; requires at least one hour of such training be provided by the committee on open government or an appropriate entity in relation to compliance with the open meetings law and if not provided, a justification shall be given.

NY S02598

Expands the training time for local municipalities in relation to the open meetings law; requires at least one hour of such training be provided by the committee on open government or an appropriate entity in relation to compliance with the open meetings law and if not provided, a justification shall be given.

NY S09777

Requires entities that submit records to state agencies that are excepted from disclosure under FOIL to periodically re-apply for the exception.

NY A01410

Requires entities that submit records to state agencies that are excepted from disclosure under FOIL to periodically re-apply for the exception.

NY SB329

Requiring the county appraiser to submit a single property appraisal report at the valuation appeal hearing before the regular division of the state board of tax appeals.

NY SB5334

AN ACT Relating to adding the department of natural resources' civil enforcement decisions under RCW 76.04.205 to appeals that may be heard by the pollution control hearings board;

Similar Bills

CA AB2570

Elderly Parole Program.

MN SF1826

Payment rates establishment for certain substance use disorder treatment services

MN HF1994

Payment rates established for certain substance use disorder treatment services, and vendor eligibility recodified for payments from the behavioral health fund.

TX HB1080

Relating to the publication of required notice by a political subdivision by alternative media.

CA SB680

Sex offender registration: unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor.

CA AB387

An act to amend Section 219 of the Code of Civil Procedure, relating to juries.

CA SB689

Local jurisdictions: district-based elections.

US HB31

Cover Outstanding Vulnerable Expansion-eligible Residents Now Act or the COVER Now Act This bill establishes a demonstration program to allow local governments to provide health benefits to the Medicaid expansion population in states that have not expanded Medicaid. Under the program, local governments may provide coverage for individuals who are newly eligible for Medicaid under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (i.e., the Medicaid expansion population) for a maximum of 10 years, or until their respective states expand Medicaid. The bill provides a 100% federal matching rate for the first three years of program participation. The bill prohibits states from taking certain actions against participating localities, such as withholding funding, increasing taxes, or restricting provider participation. States that violate these requirements are subject to certain funding penalties.