New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A972

Introduced
1/9/24  

Caption

Prohibits imposition of builder's remedy in exclusionary zoning litigation.

Impact

If enacted, A972 is likely to directly affect how municipalities manage their zoning regulations and respond to litigation concerning affordable housing. By eliminating the builder's remedy—an incentive for developers to provide market-rate housing—it compels localities to seek alternative remedies when they fall short of their housing obligations. Notably, this move underscores a shift in strategy towards enhancing the availability of affordable housing rather than facilitating the growth of market-rate developments which do not serve the lower-income population adequately.

Summary

Assembly Bill A972 seeks to abolish the imposition of the builder's remedy in exclusionary zoning litigation. The builder's remedy has been criticized for enabling the creation of an excessive amount of market-rate housing in densely populated areas, ultimately hindering the development of affordable housing. The legislation reflects a preference for resolving disputes regarding exclusionary zoning through mediation rather than through court-imposed solutions, as currently practiced. The New Jersey Legislature acknowledges the inadequacies that municipalities have faced in meeting the state's affordable housing obligations over the last forty years.

Contention

Opponents of the bill may argue that restricting the builder's remedy could remove a valuable tool that developers use to negotiate zoning changes that could ultimately lead to some level of new housing construction. Supporters, however, contend that this legal mechanism has failed to produce sufficient affordable housing and that it has primarily benefitted profit-oriented developers. The bill seeks to create a more balanced approach by potentially leading to other remedies that may be more conducive to enhancing affordable housing availability and meeting the needs of low and moderate-income residents.

Companion Bills

NJ A250

Carry Over Prohibits imposition of builder's remedy in exclusionary zoning litigation.

NJ S617

Carry Over Prohibits imposition of builder's remedy in exclusionary zoning litigation.

Previously Filed As

NJ A628

Prohibits imposition of builder's remedy in exclusionary zoning litigation.

NJ ACR138

Proposes amendment to New Jersey Constitution to prohibit exclusionary zoning and clarify municipal obligations regarding affordable housing construction.

NJ SCR52

Proposes amendment to New Jersey Constitution to prohibit exclusionary zoning and clarify municipal obligations regarding affordable housing construction.

NJ H2348

Relative to exclusionary zoning

NJ A630

Limits to 14 days effective period of certain emergency orders, rules, or regulations.

NJ A2354

Eliminates smoking ban exemption for casinos and simulcasting facilities.

NJ A617

Establishes State definition of antisemitism.

NJ A637

Authorizes proportional property tax exemption for honorably discharged veterans having a service-connected permanent disability and proclaims that the State shall reimburse municipalities for cost of exemption.

NJ ACR29

Applies to Congress for an Article V Convention of States to limit certain powers of the federal government and terms of office.

NJ A259

Criminalizes unlawful occupancy of dwellings.

Similar Bills

NJ A628

Prohibits imposition of builder's remedy in exclusionary zoning litigation.

HI SB2966

Relating To Property Insurance.

NC S695

Incent Development Finance District Funding

PA HB609

In general provisions relating to residential real property, further providing for definitions; and, in seller disclosures, further providing for application of chapter and providing for disclosure of construction defects.

VA HR725

Commending James R. Jones Builder, Inc.

WA HB2304

Increasing the supply of condominiums by expanding the types of condominium buildings that may be subject to an express warranty of quality and express warranty insurance coverage.

NJ S3255

Establishes process to exempt municipality from certain fair share affordable housing obligations based on flood risk.

MO SB1484

Creates new provisions relating to progressive design-build contracts