New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A5023

Introduced
11/14/24  

Caption

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

Impact

The introduction of A5023 is expected to impact state laws by reinforcing the legal consequences for obstructing law enforcement efforts—most notably by refusing to provide valid identification upon arrest. Current laws outline penalties for providing false information connected to motor vehicle or insurance fraud violations; however, this bill expands the scope of those penalties. Under the proposed legislation, the consequences align with the existing penalties for false information offenses, creating a more stringent enforcement mechanism against such acts.

Summary

Assembly Bill A5023 aims to establish penalties for individuals who withhold identification or refuse to provide their true identity in order to hinder their own apprehension or prosecution. By amending N.J.S.2C:29-3, the bill specifically addresses incidents where a person's failure to cooperate with law enforcement efforts to establish their identity may obstruct investigations related to various offenses. The legislation sets forth clear definitions regarding hindering apprehension, outlining various methods by which an individual can hinder their prosecution through actions such as suppressing evidence or giving false information to law enforcement officers.

Contention

While supporters of the bill argue that establishing clear penalties for withholding identification is crucial for effective law enforcement and public safety, critics may raise concerns about potential abuses of power and the implications for civil liberties. The nuances within law enforcement's interaction with the public and the required balance between compliance and individual's rights are expected to be points of significant debate as the bill progresses through legislative approval.

Companion Bills

NJ S300

Same As Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ A1106

Carry Over Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ S3483

Carry Over Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

Previously Filed As

NJ A486

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ S422

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ A835

Increases penalty for harboring or concealing certain sex offenders.

NJ S933

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ A213

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ A479

Establishes affirmative defense to prosecution for any crime committed by victim of human trafficking under certain circumstances.

NJ A260

Establishes pilot program to provide training at no cost to certain persons seeking firearms purchaser identification card, permit to purchase handgun, or permit to carry handgun.

NJ S2972

Enhances penalties for threats against certain public servants, establishes crime of doxxing, and enhances penalties for improper use of personal identifying information.

NJ SB155

Adding harboring or concealing a person who has violated terms of probation to the crime of obstructing apprehension or prosecution.

NJ S1270

Eliminates statute of limitations for human trafficking prosecutions and extends statute of limitations for civil cases arising from human trafficking.

Similar Bills

NJ S422

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ A486

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ S933

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ A213

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

LA HB303

Creates the Fugitive Apprehension Unit within the office of the attorney general (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

NJ A835

Increases penalty for harboring or concealing certain sex offenders.

MI HB4993

Housing: landlord and tenants; notice requirements for early lease termination for certain victims of violence; expand. Amends sec. 1b of 1972 PA 348 (MCL 554.601b).

MN SF4371

Certain Bureau of Criminal Apprehension grants to local law enforcement as reimbursements clarification provision, recording of crimes law modifications, determination of how certain criminal records are ineligible for sealing process establishment, and orders of protection for access by law enforcement provided by the court requirement provision