New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A4994

Introduced
10/24/24  

Caption

Requires adoption of joint resolution before Attorney General files amicus brief in any state or federal court in which State is not party.

Impact

The bill seeks to prevent the Attorney General from unilaterally representing New Jersey's interests in cases outside of its direct involvement. This change reflects concerns over recent actions taken by Attorney General Matt Platkin, particularly his support for an amicus brief against Tennessee's policy on gender-affirming care for transgender youth, which some legislators fear could misrepresent state priorities. Proponents of A4994 argue that legal decisions should be transparently debated within the democratic process, reinforcing the principle that appointees like the Attorney General should not take significant policy positions without the explicit consent of the elected legislative body.

Summary

Assembly Bill A4994 proposes significant changes to the procedure by which the Attorney General of New Jersey can file amicus briefs in state or federal courts where New Jersey is not a party. The bill mandates that before the Attorney General is permitted to file an amicus brief, a joint resolution must be adopted by both houses of the legislature and signed by the Governor. This requirement is aimed at ensuring that the legal positions taken by the Attorney General align with the decisions made by elected officials, thereby enhancing accountability and representation of New Jersey's citizens. The bill underscores the importance of transparency and collective decision-making in matters that could influence state policy and the public interest.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding A4994 include debates about the balance of power between the Attorney General, the Governor, and the legislature. Supporters contend that the bill will enhance democratic accountability and ensure that high-profile legal positions do not emerge from cabinet members without appropriate oversight. Critics, however, may argue that the legislation could inhibit the Attorney General’s ability to act swiftly on urgent legal matters, potentially hampering timely responses to pressing issues. The bill may also raise discussions about the appropriateness of legislative involvement in legal affairs, which could lead to further political friction regarding the autonomy of the Attorney General's office.

Companion Bills

NJ S3847

Same As Requires adoption of joint resolution before Attorney General files amicus brief in any state or federal court in which State is not party.

Previously Filed As

NJ A4780

Requires adoption of joint resolution before Attorney General files amicus brief in any state or federal court in which State is not party.

NJ S3231

Requires adoption of joint resolution before Attorney General files amicus brief in any state or federal court in which State is not party.

NJ HB1483

The attorney general and amicus curiae briefs.

NJ HB1090

The attorney general and amicus curiae briefs.

NJ A279

Requires commissioner of registration to move voters with undeliverable mail-in ballots to inactive file; removes such inactive voters from Statewide voter registration system following failure to vote in two consecutive federal general elections.

NJ SB239

Requiring judges to invite amicus briefing and allow intervention in certain civil cases

NJ A337

Requires Attorney General to establish educational and public information program concerning State and federal crimes of human trafficking; appropriates $75,000.

NJ HCR15

Expressing Support For The Kamehameha Schools Admissions Policy And Urging The Hawaii Attorney General To Submit An Amicus Curiae Brief To Defend The Admissions Policy In Any Future Lawsuit.

NJ HR17

Expressing Support For The Kamehameha Schools Admissions Policy And Urging The Hawaii Attorney General To Submit An Amicus Curiae Brief To Defend The Admissions Policy In Any Future Lawsuit.

NJ A678

Provides for court dismissal, with prejudice, of civil actions for which lis pendens notices are filed under certain circumstances.

Similar Bills

IL SB2087

STATES ATTY-PEACE OFCR-PRIVACY

CA SB605

State attorneys and administrative law judges: compensation.

TX HB2530

Relating to special appointments in suits affecting the parent-child relationship.

LA SB454

Provides for a population based allocation of assistant district attorney positions in the state. (7/1/26) (OR +$397,950 GF EX See Note)

LA HB719

Provides relative to the number of assistant district attorneys in each judicial district (RE +$2,274,000 GF EX See Note)

TX SB888

Relating to the attorney general's defense of a district or county attorney against certain lawsuits in federal court.

TX SB1026

Relating to the authority of the attorney general to prosecute criminal offenses prescribed by the election laws of this state.

TX SB2501

Relating to selection of an attorney by an indigent parent as attorney ad litem for the parent in certain suits affecting the parent-child relationship.