New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

New Jersey Senate Bill S3483

Introduced
1/19/23  

Caption

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

Impact

The bill's amendments to N.J.S.2C:29-3 would impose similar penalties on those who withhold identification as they would face for providing false information to law enforcement. This change means that those found guilty of this act would be subject to significant criminal penalties, which could include imprisonment and monetary fines. Specifically, the act outlines various degrees of crimes associated with the offenses of hindering and includes the current penalties under New Jersey law, like imprisonment for third degree and fourth degree crimes.

Summary

Senate Bill S3483 seeks to amend New Jersey's law regarding hindering apprehension or prosecution, specifically addressing the act of withholding identification. The bill stipulates that if a person refuses to provide valid identification or their true identity when requested by law enforcement upon arrest, they are hindering their own apprehension and prosecution. This change is aimed at strengthening law enforcement's ability to enforce the law effectively and ensuring that individuals cannot evade legal accountability simply by withholding their identity.

Contention

Discussions surrounding the bill may reveal points of contention regarding the balance between law enforcement interests and individual rights. Opponents might argue that increasing penalties for withholding identification could lead to disproportionate consequences for individuals, particularly among marginalized communities. Supporters, on the other hand, would likely contend that these changes are necessary to prevent individuals from obstructing justice, thereby strengthening public safety and law enforcement efficacy.

Companion Bills

NJ A1106

Same As Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

Previously Filed As

NJ S422

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ A486

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ A835

Increases penalty for harboring or concealing certain sex offenders.

NJ S933

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ A213

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ S1010

Establishes offense of reckless trespass involving wild animal; establishes penalties; establishes liability for resulting harm to wild animal.

NJ A260

Establishes pilot program to provide training at no cost to certain persons seeking firearms purchaser identification card, permit to purchase handgun, or permit to carry handgun.

NJ SB155

Adding harboring or concealing a person who has violated terms of probation to the crime of obstructing apprehension or prosecution.

NJ S2972

Enhances penalties for threats against certain public servants, establishes crime of doxxing, and enhances penalties for improper use of personal identifying information.

NJ S2174

Establishes crime of doxxing.

Similar Bills

NJ S422

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ A486

Establishes penalty for withholding identification to hinder apprehension or prosecution.

NJ S933

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ A213

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

LA HB303

Creates the Fugitive Apprehension Unit within the office of the attorney general (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

NJ A835

Increases penalty for harboring or concealing certain sex offenders.

MI HB4993

Housing: landlord and tenants; notice requirements for early lease termination for certain victims of violence; expand. Amends sec. 1b of 1972 PA 348 (MCL 554.601b).

MN SF4371

Certain Bureau of Criminal Apprehension grants to local law enforcement as reimbursements clarification provision, recording of crimes law modifications, determination of how certain criminal records are ineligible for sealing process establishment, and orders of protection for access by law enforcement provided by the court requirement provision