New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A5186

Introduced
2/13/23  

Caption

Prohibits adoption of State and local rules that prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered kitchen appliances.

Impact

The passage of A5186 would have significant implications on both state and local law governing kitchen appliance installations. By prohibiting local entities from enforcing bans on fossil fuel appliances, the bill effectively centralizes regulatory authority, allowing residents and businesses to continue using natural gas appliances without legal interference. Supporters argue this move promotes energy choice and preserves access to reliable fuel sources, while detractors may view it as a step back in the effort to transition to more sustainable energy solutions.

Summary

Assembly Bill A5186, introduced in the New Jersey Legislature, seeks to prohibit any state agency, county, or municipality from adopting rules, regulations, or ordinances that would ban the use of fossil fuel-powered appliances, specifically in residential and commercial kitchens. This includes natural gas-powered appliances such as ovens and stoves, which are commonplace in many households and restaurants across the state. The bill was presented with the intention of protecting the rights of individuals and businesses to utilize widely accepted cooking appliances, despite the rising challenges posed by environmental regulations.

Conclusion

In summary, Assembly Bill A5186 highlights the ongoing debate between energy choice and environmental responsibility. As the bill is discussed further in committee sessions, it will likely face scrutiny from both sides, weighing the benefits of consumer choice against the potential long-term ramifications for state energy policy and environmental health.

Contention

Notably, the bill does not interfere with programs aimed at incentivizing the use of electric appliances, leaving room for voluntary measures promoting greener alternatives. Opposition to A5186 may stem from environmental advocacy groups and state officials focused on climate change initiatives, who argue that continued reliance on fossil fuels, including natural gas, undermines efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and combat climate change.

Companion Bills

NJ S3560

Same As Prohibits adoption of State and local rules that prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered kitchen appliances.

Previously Filed As

NJ A163

Prohibits adoption of State and local rules that prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered kitchen appliances.

NJ S1339

Prohibits adoption of State and local rules that prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered kitchen appliances.

NJ A4614

"Affordable Home Energy Protection Act"; prohibits adoption of State or local rules that restrict the use of certain fossil-fuel powered appliances or heating systems.

NJ S1929

"Affordable Home Energy Protection Act"; prohibits adoption of State or local rules that restrict the use of certain fossil-fuel powered appliances or heating systems.

NJ A5130

"Vehicle Choice Protection Act"; prohibits State agencies from adopting rules, regulations, or policies that restrict or prohibit sale, registration, or use of new internal combustion vehicles in State.

NJ A1254

Prohibits adoption of any State rule or regulation mandating electric heating or water heating systems in buildings prior to issuance of DCA report.

NJ SCR18

Amends Constitution to prohibit construction of new fossil fuel power plants.

NJ A180

Prohibits State from imposing mileage-based user fee; prohibits use of State funding for any program, study, or pilot program related to imposition of mileage-based user fee.

NJ A4971

Prohibits DEP and other State agencies from adopting certain rules and regulations without Legislative approval.

NJ A5029

Prohibits for 10 years applicability of new State and local rules and regulations to certain manufacturing facilities.

Similar Bills

NJ S1339

Prohibits adoption of State and local rules that prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered kitchen appliances.

NJ A163

Prohibits adoption of State and local rules that prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered kitchen appliances.

CA AB852

Air pollution: oxides of nitrogen: furnaces and water heaters.

NJ A4614

"Affordable Home Energy Protection Act"; prohibits adoption of State or local rules that restrict the use of certain fossil-fuel powered appliances or heating systems.

NJ S1929

"Affordable Home Energy Protection Act"; prohibits adoption of State or local rules that restrict the use of certain fossil-fuel powered appliances or heating systems.

MS HB1073

Consumer freedom of choice; protect in the purchase of farm equipment, vehicles and lawn tools.

MS SB2062

Consumer Freedom of Choice Act; amend to include motor vehicles, tools and farm equipment.

MI SB0084

Construction: housing; ordinance prohibiting the use of energy-efficient appliances in new or existing residential buildings; prohibit local units of government from enacting. Amends sec. 13a of 1972 PA 230 (MCL 125.1513a).