New Hampshire 2024 Regular Session

New Hampshire Senate Bill SB252

Introduced
1/24/23  
Refer
1/24/23  
Report Pass
2/16/23  
Report Pass
2/22/23  
Report Pass
3/16/23  
Engrossed
3/28/23  
Refer
3/28/23  
Report Pass
11/17/23  
Refer
1/3/24  

Caption

Relative to the release of a defendant pending trial, directing the establishment of an electronic monitoring program for criminal defendants released on bail, and making an appropriation therefor.

Impact

This legislation is expected to significantly affect the legal landscape in New Hampshire by streamlining the bail hearing process, particularly for serious offenses. It is estimated that the bill could lead to a substantial number of additional bail hearings each year—in the vicinity of 2,700—further taxing the judicial system. Consequently, the bill may require state and local jurisdictions to allocate more resources, including the need for additional judges and court assistants to handle the increased caseload, as well as potentially higher costs for indigent defense as public defenders manage an uptick in cases due to the added complexity of the pretrial detention framework.

Summary

Senate Bill 252 aims to amend the current process surrounding the release of defendants pending trial, specifically addressing cases that involve serious offenses such as homicide, assault, and domestic violence. The bill establishes a framework that presumes certain defendants pose a danger to the public, mandating their detention for up to 36 hours following arrest. The intent is to enhance public safety by providing judicial oversight on bail decisions during the critical period before arraignment, thereby ensuring that potentially dangerous individuals are not released into the community without adequate consideration of their risk to public safety.

Contention

However, the bill has not been without its critics. Concerns have been raised regarding the implications for civil liberties, particularly how the presumption of danger might affect defendants who do not pose a legitimate threat but who are nonetheless detained for longer periods. Furthermore, there are fears that the increased burden on the judicial system may lead to delays in due process for those accused of crimes, effectively extending their time in custody before the opportunity for trial. Advocates for criminal justice reform argue that while public safety is essential, the measures proposed in SB 252 might exacerbate an already overburdened system, impacting individuals disproportionately and complicating an already nuanced legal process.

Companion Bills

NH SB252

Carry Over Relative to release of a defendant pending trial.

Previously Filed As

NH HB413

Relating to the release of certain defendants detained in jail pending trial.

NH HB480

relative to restoration of competency to stand trial for criminal defendants.

NH HB480

Relative to restoration of competency to stand trial for criminal defendants.

NH SB26112

Concerning defendants who fail to appear in court, and, in connection therewith, permitting certain conditions on pretrial release for defendants who have previously failed to appear.

NH A4372

"Ending the Criminal Revolving Door Act"; restricts pretrial release of certain defendants; sets conditions for pretrial release of certain first-time offenders; requires revocation of pretrial release under certain circumstances.

NH SB135

Clarifying conditions for pretrial release and maximum bail amount for certain defendants

NH SB590

Clarifying conditions for pretrial release and maximum bail amount for certain defendants

NH S3338

Authorizes the court to issue restraining orders to defendants charged with a crime as a condition of release on bail.

NH A4476

Authorizes the court to issue restraining orders to defendants charged with a crime as a condition of release on bail.

NH A786

Clarifies procedures for revocation of pretrial release for certain defendants.

Similar Bills

ME LD2085

An Act to Include a Certain Emergency Communications Position at the Department of Public Safety in the 1998 Special Plan

ME LD579

An Act to Include Certain Nurses Under the 1998 Special Plan for Retirement

ME LD794

An Act to Include Judicial Marshals in the 1998 Special Plan for Retirement

ME LD137

An Act to Expand the 1998 Special Retirement Plan to Include Employees Who Work for the Office of Chief Medical Examiner

ME LD2067

An Act to Include Community Mental Health Workers Under the 1998 Special Plan for Retirement

IA HF182

A bill for an act relating to controlled substances, including certain controlled substances schedules and precursor substances reporting requirements, making penalties applicable, and including effective date provisions. (Formerly HSB 25.) Effective date: 03/28/2025.

IA SSB1080

A bill for an act relating to controlled substances, including certain controlled substances schedules and precursor substances reporting requirements, making penalties applicable, and including effective date provisions.(See SF 305.)

IA HSB25

A bill for an act relating to controlled substances, including certain controlled substances schedules and precursor substances reporting requirements, making penalties applicable, and including effective date provisions.(See HF 182.)