North Carolina 2023-2024 Regular Session

North Carolina Senate Bill S336

Introduced
3/20/23  

Caption

Informed Consent Certain Procedures

Impact

The bill amends existing laws in North Carolina’s General Statutes and introduces a requirement that a written or electronic consent form be obtained specifically for pelvic and rectal exams on unconscious patients. This update aims to enhance patient protection and ensure that consent processes are formalized and transparent. Violations of these provisions could result in charges of a Class A1 misdemeanor, thereby establishing a strong legal framework for accountability regarding patient consent. The effective date for these changes is set for October 1, 2023, and they will apply to all examinations conducted thereafter.

Summary

Senate Bill 336, titled 'Informed Consent Certain Procedures,' seeks to establish clear guidelines for obtaining informed consent specifically for pelvic and rectal examinations performed on anesthetized or unconscious patients. This legislation requires health care providers to secure informed consent from patients or their representatives prior to conducting such examinations, ensuring that patients' rights and autonomy are respected, especially when they are unable to consent due to their anesthetized state. The bill encompasses definitions of key terms such as 'health care provider,' 'anesthetized patient,' and 'unconscious patient,' laying the foundation for the procedures that must be followed to obtain consent.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 336 appears to be predominantly supportive, as it reinforces ethical practices in the medical field and protects vulnerable patients who cannot voice their consent. Senators Krawiec, Galey, and Adcock, who sponsored the bill, seem to be responding to public concerns regarding medical practices and patient autonomy. Supporters of the bill view it as a crucial step towards ensuring that patients' rights are upheld during procedures where consent is particularly challenging to obtain. Though the discussions have been largely positive, there may be some hesitation or opposition from individuals concerned about the implications for educational practices within medical training.

Contention

While the bill aims to fortify patient rights, opponents may challenge the practicality and impact this legislation could have on medical training practices. The stipulation that consent forms must be completed each time a pelvic or rectal examination is performed on an anesthetized patient might complicate the training process for medical professionals, especially trainees. Nonetheless, proponents argue that the necessity of informed consent far outweighs any potential challenges, emphasizing the importance of ethical standards in medical examinations and ensuring transparency and respect for patient autonomy.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NC HB548

AN ACT relating to informed consent for medical examinations.

NC HB795

AN ACT relating to informed consent for medical examinations.

NC SB288

Disclosure of Certain Information; certain examinations on an anesthetized or unconscious patient without prior informed consent; prohibit

NC SB0090

Consent for pelvic, prostate, and rectal exams.

NC S1485

Providing for safe and consensual sensitive examinations

NC HB1351

Consent for pelvic, prostate, and rectal exams.

NC H2401

Providing for safe and consensual sensitive examinations

NC SF183

Informed consent for sensitive examinations of and anesthetized or unconscious patient requirement

NC SB509

Prohibiting certain medical exams on anesthetized patients

NC SF2899

Informed consent required for sensitive examinations performed on an anesthetized or unconscious patient provision

Similar Bills

NJ S2891

Prohibits certain steering and marketing practices involving dispensing of prescription drugs and drug samples.

NJ A1213

Requires hospital to install and operate electronic monitoring device at request of incapacitated patient or patient's legal representative.

LA SB273

Provides relative to inpatient licensed facilities. (8/1/26) (EN INCREASE GF EX See Note)

MI SB0033

Probate: patient advocates; withholding life-sustaining treatment for a patient who is pregnant; allow. Amends secs. 5507 & 5509 of 1998 PA 386 (MCL 700.5507 & 700.5509).

IL HB1332

HOSPITAL EMERGENCY CONTACT

AZ HB2706

Mental health; intensive treatment orders

TX SB124

Relating to hospital patients' rights and hospital policies and procedures; providing an administrative penalty.

TX SB984

Relating to access to individualized investigational treatments for patients with life-threatening or severely debilitating illnesses.