Minnesota 2023-2024 Regular Session

Minnesota House Bill HF1370

Introduced
2/6/23  
Refer
2/6/23  
Refer
2/20/23  
Refer
3/6/23  
Report Pass
3/15/23  
Engrossed
4/3/23  
Refer
4/3/23  
Report Pass
4/4/23  
Report Pass
5/12/23  
Report Pass
5/12/23  
Report Pass
5/12/23  
Report Pass
5/12/23  
Report Pass
5/15/23  
Report Pass
5/16/23  
Report Pass
5/16/23  
Report Pass
5/17/23  
Report Pass
5/18/23  
Enrolled
5/23/23  
Passed
5/26/23  
Passed
5/26/23  
Chaptered
5/26/23  

Caption

Cause of action for nonconsensual dissemination of deep fake sexual images established, crime of using deep fake technology to influence an election established, and crime for nonconsensual dissemination of deep fake sexual images established.

Impact

If passed, HF1370 would create several new laws in Minnesota that impose civil and criminal liabilities for the misuse of deep fake technologies. It introduces a cause of action for individuals harmed by the unauthorized spread of deep fake images, enabling them to seek damages, including financial losses and mental anguish. Additionally, it penalizes the dissemination of deep fakes intended to impair a political candidate's electoral prospects, thus aiming to protect electoral processes from malicious misinformation.

Summary

House File 1370 addresses emerging concerns around deep fake technologies by establishing legal frameworks against the nonconsensual dissemination of deep fake sexual images and the use of such technology to influence elections. This bill specifically defines what constitutes a 'deep fake' and sets forth the legal implications of both its creation and distribution without consent. The measure aims to enhance public safety and personal privacy in the digital age, where technological advancements can compromise individuals' reputations and electoral integrity.

Sentiment

The discussion surrounding HF1370 indicates a mixed sentiment. Proponents argue that the bill is a necessary step to safeguard individuals from abuse in an increasingly digital world, while opponents express concerns over the vagueness of definitions and potential ramifications for artistic expression and free speech. The polarization reflects broader societal anxieties about privacy in the context of rapidly evolving technology and its misuse.

Contention

A notable point of contention in HF1370 revolves around the definitions of 'deep fake' and the thresholds for liability. Critics argue that overly broad interpretations of what constitutes malicious intent could impede legitimate uses of similar technologies, such as parody or political satire. As legislators weigh these concerns, the balance between protecting individuals and preserving creative freedoms remains a focal point of debate.

Companion Bills

MN SF1394

Similar To Cause of action establishment for nonconsensual dissemination of deep fake sexual images

Previously Filed As

MN HF5157

Nonconsensual creation, possession, and dissemination of nudification images prohibited.

MN SF5310

Nonconsensual creation, possession, and dissemination prohibition of nudification images

MN HB4048

Criminal procedure: sentencing guidelines; guidelines for dissemination of deep fake sexual images; enact. Amends sec. 17b, ch. XVII of 1927 PA 175 (MCL 777.17b). TIE BAR WITH: HB 4047'25

MN HB1092

Relating to the unlawful production or distribution of sexually explicit images or videos using deep fake technology; increasing a criminal penalty.

MN HB387

Relating to the unlawful production or distribution of sexually explicit images or videos using deep fake technology; increasing a criminal penalty.

MN HB449

Relating to the unlawful production or distribution of sexually explicit media using deep fake technology.

MN SF662

Civil cause of action establishment for the nonconsensual removal of a condom

MN A2736

Updates certain crimes to include nonconsensual pornographic deepfake threats and disclosure.

MN S3303

Updates certain crimes to include nonconsensual pornographic deepfake threats and disclosure.

MN HB525

Election Law - Influencing a Voter By Dissemination of a Deepfake - Prohibition

Similar Bills

CA SB277

Criminal procedure: search of persons.

CA AB1464

Housing preferences.

CA AB2161

Medi-Cal: redeterminations and work or community engagement.

CA AB2066

Triggering event: pregnancy.

CA SB257

PARENT Act.

IA HF2731

A bill for an act establishing the percentage of income payment plan program to be administered by the department of health and human services.

HI HB286

Relating To The Individual Housing Account Program.

HI HB286

Relating To The Individual Housing Account Program.