Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.
Summary
SCR184 is a Senate Concurrent Resolution requesting the Hawaiʻi Civil Rights Commission to study how existing Hawaii anti-discrimination laws apply to algorithmic and automated decision systems, including artificial intelligence tools. The resolution focuses on systems used in employment screening, tenant selection, credit decisions, and public benefits eligibility, where automated tools may affect protected classes and civil rights outcomes.
The resolution asks the Commission to assess whether current law already gives it enough authority to investigate and remedy algorithmic discrimination, identify jurisdictional and evidentiary problems, consider whether guidance or rulemaking would help regulated entities and the public, and evaluate whether a complaint or intake process should be created for these claims. It also directs the Commission to recommend any needed legislation and report back to the Legislature before the 2027 Regular Session.
Impact
SCR184 does not directly amend Hawaii statutes or create new legal duties. Instead, it initiates an administrative review by the Hawaiʻi Civil Rights Commission of whether existing civil rights and anti-discrimination laws are sufficient to address discrimination caused by automated decision-making, and whether legislative or regulatory changes may be needed. If the Commission’s report leads to follow-up legislation, the resolution could influence future enforcement authority, complaint procedures, and civil rights protections related to AI and other automated systems.
Sentiment
The available legislative history suggests generally favorable sentiment toward the resolution. It passed the Senate Judiciary Committee unanimously and without amendment, indicating broad support for studying the issue rather than immediately changing the law. The resolution’s framing around fairness, equal protection, and keeping civil rights protections current with technology likely contributed to the positive reception.
Contention
There is little evidence of direct opposition in the available record, but the resolution itself identifies the main areas of concern: whether existing law clearly covers algorithmic discrimination, and whether such claims pose novel jurisdictional, evidentiary, or enforcement challenges. Potential points of contention in any later legislation could include how to define algorithmic or automated decision systems, how much disclosure or oversight should be required of private entities, and whether the Commission should receive new complaint-handling or rulemaking authority.
Same As
Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.
Same As
Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.
Requesting The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs To Convene A Working Group To Examine And Consider The Transfer Of Native Hawaiian Burial Site Management Under Chapter 6e, Hawaii Revised Statutes, From The State Historic Preservation Division To The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.
Requesting The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs To Convene A Working Group To Examine And Consider The Transfer Of Native Hawaiian Burial Site Management Under Chapter 6e, Hawaii Revised Statutes, From The State Historic Preservation Division To The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.
Requesting The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs To Convene A Working Group To Examine And Consider The Transfer Of Native Hawaiian Burial Site Management Under Chapter 6e, Hawaii Revised Statutes, From The State Historic Preservation Division To The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.
Requesting The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs To Convene A Working Group To Examine And Consider The Transfer Of Native Hawaiian Burial Site Management Under Chapter 6e, Hawaii Revised Statutes, From The State Historic Preservation Division To The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.
Requesting The Auditor To Conduct An Audit Of The Moneys Appropriated To The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands Pursuant To Act 279, Session Laws Of Hawaii 2022.
Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.
Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.
Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.