Louisiana 2023 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SR170

Introduced
6/3/23  
Introduced
6/3/23  
Refer
6/4/23  
Refer
6/4/23  
Report Pass
6/6/23  
Passed
6/7/23  

Caption

Creates a task force to study and make recommendations regarding crime against nature by solicitation.

Impact

By forming the task force, SR170 aims to critically examine the implications of the crime against nature by solicitation statute and its enforcement. This initiative stems from previous judicial findings in cases such as Lawrence v. Texas, which upheld personal privacy rights in consensual relationships, suggesting a need to reevaluate outdated laws that may infringe on individual rights. The task force is charged with researching the impacts of enforcement and proposing legislative recommendations as necessary, potentially influencing state laws on solicitation and sex work.

Summary

Senate Resolution No. 170, authored by Senator Duplessis, establishes a task force focused on the enforcement of the crime against nature by solicitation statute in Louisiana. This statute prohibits solicitation with the intent to engage in unnatural carnal copulation for compensation, yet lacks specific definitions for certain terms, leading to potential constitutional concerns. The resolution acknowledges the disparities in sentencing, particularly noting that male sex workers are more likely charged with crime against nature compared to prostitution, resulting in harsher penalties for similar behaviors.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around SR170 appears to be cautiously optimistic, highlighting a growing awareness of the complexities surrounding criminalization in intimate relationships. Advocates for LGBTQ rights and criminal justice reform express hope that the task force's deliberate study will lead to more equitable and just laws that reflect contemporary understandings of personal autonomy and dignity. Yet, there exists an undercurrent of skepticism among some stakeholders who worry about the potential for mere recommendations without substantive legislative action.

Contention

Notable points of contention stem from the historical context of the crime against nature statute, which has been criticized for its ambiguous language and perceived discrimination against LGBTQ individuals, particularly males. Critics have raised concerns that the lack of clarity in legal definitions continues to perpetuate inequalities in enforcement and sentencing. The task force will attempt to address these long-standing issues, but it must navigate a complex landscape where all stakeholders feel heard and represented, underscoring the contentious nature of reform in this arena.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA SCR40

Creates the K-12 School Safety Task Force to study and make recommendations relative to school safety and security.

LA SCR62

Creates a statewide task force to study and make recommendations on implementing a comprehensive plan to address property blight within the state.

LA SR202

Creates a task force to study the effectiveness of technology and research parks and to make recommendations on its findings.

LA SR148

UTILITIES: Creates the Utility Assistance Coordination Task Force to study and make recommendations regarding coordination of utility assistance programs in the state.

LA SCR65

SCHOOLS: Creates the K-12 Student Success Pathways Task Force to study and make recommendations on a statewide plan for advising students on career and academic pathways in K-12 public schools.

LA HCR64

Requests a study to make recommendations regarding behavioral health courts

LA SR195

Creates a task force to study and make recommendations relative to polices that promote energy self-generation, industrial microgrids, and expedited permitting in the state of Louisiana.

LA HR336

Creates a study group to examine and make policy recommendations regarding insurance premium taxes and associated credits and exemptions

LA HB2301

Crimes against nature; taking indecent liberties with children, penalties.

LA S274

Repeal Crime Against Nature Law

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.