Louisiana 2023 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB598

Introduced
3/31/23  
Introduced
3/31/23  
Refer
3/31/23  
Refer
3/31/23  
Refer
4/10/23  
Refer
5/11/23  

Caption

Amends definitions relative to the crime of abortion

Impact

The implications of HB 598 are significant for state laws regarding abortion and medical care related to pregnancy. By clarifying what constitutes an abortion, the bill effectively aims to prevent legal repercussions for medical professionals treating ectopic pregnancies. This change is intended to align state law more closely with medical guidelines and practices, ensuring that critical healthcare procedures can continue without fear of being classified as criminal acts. However, this shift could also provoke debates regarding the broader implications for reproductive rights within the state.

Summary

House Bill 598, introduced by Representative Newell, aims to amend the definitions surrounding the crime of abortion. Specifically, the bill seeks to clarify certain medical procedures that are not considered abortions, including the removal of an ectopic pregnancy. Additionally, the proposed legislation maintains that the use of methotrexate to treat ectopic pregnancies is not classified as an abortion, although it proposes the elimination of this exception. Moreover, the bill revises the definition of 'medically futile' to include both congenital anomalies and situations where the pregnancy poses a significant health risk to the mother.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 598 is mixed, reflecting the contentious status of abortion-related legislation in the state. Supporters argue that the bill is a necessary update to ensure that medical professionals can act in the best interests of their patients without the threat of legal consequences. Conversely, opponents might view this as an incremental approach to expanding restrictions surrounding abortion, fearing that it could lead to further erosions of reproductive autonomy under the guise of medical clarification.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the removal of the exception for methotrexate treatment. Critics may argue that this change could hinder access to necessary medical care for women experiencing ectopic pregnancies, framing it as an expanded restriction on abortion rights disguised as medical regulation. The revisions to the definition of 'medically futile' are also critical, as they potentially broaden the interpretation of what qualifies for an abortion, raising concerns about how this would affect women's health decisions moving forward.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HB1257

Amend the definition of an abortion.

LA AB546

Limitations on the definition of abortion.

LA SB553

Limitations on the definition of abortion.

LA HF2788

A bill for an act relating to abortions including definitions, informed consent, dispensing of abortion-inducing drugs, and other abortion-related provisions. (Formerly HF 2563, HSB 704.) Effective date: 07/01/2026.

LA HB0042

Regulation of surgical abortions.

LA HB1307

Relating to the definition of abortion.

LA HB0232

Medicaid Abortion Payment Amendments

LA HB3410

Establishes and modifies provisions relating to the definition of abortion

LA SB31

Relating to exceptions to otherwise prohibited abortions based on a physician's reasonable medical judgment.

LA A09198

Enacts the "life appropriation act" prohibiting state funding for abortions and related costs; regulates abortions and prohibits dismemberment abortions.

Similar Bills

NJ A1679

Provides certain deceptive practices in advertising of pregnancy-related services or health care services violate consumer fraud act.*

NJ S3319

Provides certain deceptive practices in advertising of pregnancy-related services violate consumer fraud act.

KS HB2635

Enacting the pregnancy center autonomy and rights of expression act to protect the ability of private pregnancy centers to provide life-affirming care.

NJ A3753

Requires crisis pregnancy centers to disclose certain information in multiple languages.

SC H3504

Pregnancy CARE Act

SC H3012

Pregnancy CARE Act

OK HB3194

Pregnancy centers; terms; agencies; pregnancy center; prohibitions; abortion-inducing drugs or contraception; counsel; staffing or hiring decisions; remedies; severability; effective date.

NJ SR30

Supports work of pregnancy resource centers and condemns harassment of pregnancy resource centers by AG.