Louisiana Senate Bill SB198

Louisiana 2017 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/31/17
• Refer: 3/31/17
• Refer: 4/10/17

Caption

Provides for legislative approval prior to the removal of monuments by local or political subdivisions. (gov sig)

Impact

If enacted, SB198 would significantly influence state laws relating to historical preservation and local governance. By mandating that any modifications to established public memorials and monuments receive state-level legislative approval, the bill centralizes authority over such actions at the state government level, which may limit the autonomy of local governments to address community-specific needs regarding historical representations. This could lead to a more uniform approach to historical preservation across Louisiana, mitigating variations that may arise from local decision-making.

Summary

Senate Bill 198, known as the Historical Linguistic and Cultural Origins Protection Act, seeks to protect historical monuments and memorials by requiring legislative approval prior to their relocation, removal, disturbance, or alteration. It specifies that certain items, such as museums, landmarks on national registries, and monuments that have existed for at least twenty-five years, cannot be altered without a concurrent resolution from the legislature. This bill reflects an intention to uphold Louisiana's historical and cultural heritage as a form of educational protection.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB198 appears to be polarized. Proponents argue that the bill is essential for preserving Louisiana's rich history and cultural identity, viewing it as a necessary measure to prevent hasty or politically motivated changes to historical sites. However, opponents contend that this legislation could infringe upon local control and impede the ability of communities to make decisions that reflect their unique contexts and values, especially in cases where local sentiments may challenge existing monuments.

Contention

Notable points of contention include concerns about the balance of power between state and local governments, especially regarding the management of public history and memory. Critics fear that SB198 might push specific political agendas while neglecting local voices. Additionally, there is a worry that the bill's requirements for legislative approval could delay initiatives to address and reconsider certain historical monuments that communities feel are no longer appropriate.