Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa Senate Bill SF85

Introduced
1/17/23  
Introduced
1/17/23  

Caption

A bill for an act relating to public education, including participation in surveys, analyses, activities, or evaluations by students, employees, and contractors of school districts or charter schools and prohibiting the use of certain resources or materials related to social and emotional learning.

Impact

If enacted, SF85 will reshape the landscape of public education by placing strict limitations on the types of information that can be solicited from students through surveys. Specifically, it prohibits the Department of Education from using or promoting materials associated with social and emotional learning (SEL) frameworks. By disallowing the use of these materials for educational purposes, the bill alters how schools address essential topics of emotional well-being and psychological development. This change could lead to a significant reduction in resources available for teachers and administrators who aim to support students' social-emotional health.

Summary

Senate File 85, introduced by Senator Salmon, is a significant piece of legislation aimed at regulating aspects of public education within the state. The bill addresses participation in surveys, analyses, activities, or evaluations that involve students, school employees, and contractors from school districts or charter schools. It emphasizes the need for transparency and parental involvement by mandating that parents or guardians provide written consent before any student can participate in surveys that delve into sensitive topics such as political affiliations, mental health issues, and personal behaviors. This requirement aims to protect students' privacy rights and grant parents greater control over the information shared about their children.

Contention

Debate surrounding SF85 is expected to be contentious, as it touches on the balance between student privacy rights and the necessity of social-emotional education in schools. Advocates for the bill argue that parental consent is crucial for protecting children and ensuring that families remain informed about the types of evaluations conducted in schools. Conversely, critics, including educators and mental health professionals, express concern that the bill may hinder the development of comprehensive emotional learning programs, which they believe are essential for fostering students' overall well-being. The prohibition against certain educational resources may create barriers for schools trying to implement effective SEL initiatives, potentially undermining the support systems in place for students facing emotional and psychological challenges.

Companion Bills

IA HF362

Similar To A bill for an act relating to public education, including participation in surveys, analyses, activities, or evaluations by students, employees, and contractors of school districts or charter schools and prohibiting the use of certain resources or materials related to social and emotional learning.

Previously Filed As

IA SF113

A bill for an act relating to children and students, including by modifying provisions related to a parent's or guardian's rights to make decisions affecting the parent's or guardian's child, the educational program and human growth and development curriculum provided to students enrolled in school districts, charter schools, and innovation zone schools, student health screenings, school district library programs, special education, and other duties of school districts and the governing boards of charter schools and innovation zone schools.

IA A4874

Requires certain school districts and Commissioner of Education to submit reports on social and emotional learning.

IA HF929

A bill for an act relating to school districts, including by modifying provisions related to closed sessions of meetings of the boards of directors of school districts and school district requirements to publish information regarding the school district's policies and procedures and educational materials available to students enrolled in the school district.(Formerly HSB 156.)

IA HB582

Public K-12 education; use and teaching of social-emotional learning concepts prohibited, parental consent required for certain surveys, violations constitute neglect of duty

IA HF554

A bill for an act relating to public schools, including by modifying provisions related to school district library programs and requests to remove educational materials from classrooms and school libraries.

IA SF217

A bill for an act relating to surveys administered to students or school employees.

IA SB1495

Schools; creating the Age-Appropriate Materials Act; prohibiting public school districts and public charter schools from making certain materials available to students. Effective date.

IA HSB156

A bill for an act modifying provisions related to school district requirements to publish information regarding the school district's policies and procedures and educational materials available to students in the school district.(See HF 929.)

IA HB1327

Schools; prohibiting certain students from participating in school curriculum or activities; effective date.

IA HB1327

Schools; prohibiting certain students from participating in school curriculum or activities; effective date.

Similar Bills

AR SB425

To Amend Various Provisions Of The Arkansas Code Concerning Enhanced Transportation; And To Declare An Emergency.

TX HB5663

Relating to the authority of the Wood County Central Hospital District of Wood County, Texas, to provide brain and memory care services to residents of the hospital district through the creation and operation of brain and memory health care services districts.

KY HR1

A RESOLUTION establishing the 2026 membership of the Kentucky State House of Representatives.

KY HR1

A RESOLUTION establishing the 2025 membership of the Kentucky State House of Representatives.

LA HB719

Provides relative to the number of assistant district attorneys in each judicial district (RE +$2,274,000 GF EX See Note)

KY HR1

A RESOLUTION establishing the 2022 membership of the Kentucky State House of Representatives.

LA SB454

Provides for a population based allocation of assistant district attorney positions in the state. (7/1/26) (OR +$397,950 GF EX See Note)

VA HB29

Chaptered