Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa Senate Bill SF499

Introduced
3/2/23  
Refer
6/5/23  
Introduced
3/2/23  

Caption

A bill for an act relating to damages owed by a party at fault in crashes and collisions involving commercial motor vehicles.(Formerly SF 339.)

Impact

The bill introduces a significant change in how fault in accidents involving CMVs is addressed legally. Under SF499, the party at fault is liable to compensate the owner of the damaged CMV for each day the vehicle cannot operate. This compensation is based on the average revenue generated from the vehicle during the thirty days prior to the incident. Notably, the bill states that the damages owed to the vehicle owner will not be reduced by any contributory fault on their part, which marks a departure from existing laws that diminish damages based on shared fault.

Summary

Senate File 499 addresses the responsibilities of parties at fault in crashes and collisions involving commercial motor vehicles (CMVs). The bill mandates that a party responsible for causing damage to a CMV is required to arrange and pay for a like replacement vehicle to be delivered to the owner or operator of the damaged CMV upon request. This replacement vehicle must be provided without unnecessary delay until the repairs are completed or the damaged vehicle is ready to be put back into service. Additionally, if the responsible party fails to provide a replacement vehicle, they must reimburse the owner for any costs incurred in securing a replacement, including rental charges.

Contention

Supporters of the bill argue that it provides necessary protections for CMV operators, ensuring they are not at a financial disadvantage when involved in accidents caused by others. Critics, however, may raise concerns about the implications of expanding liability in cases where multiple parties may share fault. The bill's provisions could lead to contentious legal interpretations regarding what constitutes adequate compensation and fault allocation, particularly if not all circumstances of a crash are clear-cut. This could result in increased litigation as parties navigate the revised liability landscape.

Companion Bills

IA SF339

Similar To A bill for an act relating to damages owed by a party at fault in crashes and collisions involving commercial motor vehicles.(See SF 499.)

Previously Filed As

IA SF77

A bill for an act relating to tort liability in civil actions involving commercial motor vehicles, including employer liability, noneconomic damages, punitive damages, and exemplary damages.

IA S1036

Relative to liability for accidents and collisions with vulnerable road users involving large motor vehicles and trailers

IA LB79

Provide for dismissal of certain civil actions involving commercial motor vehicles

IA HB4176

Relating to the investigation of certain motor vehicle collisions by former peace officers.

IA SB39

Relating to civil liability of a commercial motor vehicle owner or operator.

IA HB4143

Motor vehicles; modifying damage amount requiring a written report of collision; effective date.

IA HB1518

Establishing liability standards for certain vehicle collisions.

IA HB1303

Funding for Motor Vehicle Collision Prevention

IA HB4688

Relating to civil liability of a commercial motor vehicle owner or operator.

IA SF2475

A bill for an act relating to abandoned vehicles.(Formerly SF 2457, SSB 3061.)

Similar Bills

NJ A5004

Requires MVC to verify certain information concerning commercial learner's permit and commercial driver license applicants and holders to ensure persons illegally in the State do not obtain or hold such permits and licenses.

IL SB0160

TWP CODE-SOLAR/WIND FACILITIES

CA AB274

Abandoned and derelict vessels: inventory.

HI SB1482

Relating To Commercial Drivers Licensing.

HI HB1163

Relating To Commercial Drivers Licensing.

HI HB1163

Relating To Commercial Drivers Licensing.

HI SB1482

Relating To Commercial Drivers Licensing.

CA AB1796

Licensed Professional Interior Designer Practice Act.