Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa House Bill HF2007

Introduced
1/9/24  
Introduced
1/9/24  

Caption

A bill for an act relating to restitution owed by a person who is convicted of homicide by motor vehicle for unintentionally causing the death of a parent of a minor child.

Impact

The inclusion of child maintenance restitution in HF2007 would not only add to the legal obligations of offenders but also have a significant emotional and financial impact on families affected by vehicular homicides. The court will determine the amount of this restitution based on multiple factors, including the financial needs of the child and their surviving guardian, the standard of living before the incident, and the child's educational needs. The emphasis on child maintenance indicates a shift towards prioritizing the welfare of minor children left behind by such tragic circumstances.

Summary

House File 2007, introduced by Representative Collins, seeks to amend the existing laws on restitution owed by individuals convicted of homicide by motor vehicle. Specifically, the bill targets cases where the offender unintentionally causes the death of a parent of a minor child. In such instances, in addition to the standard restitution requirements, the convicted person would be liable for additional child maintenance restitution owed until the child reaches adulthood (age 18) and completes their high school education. This provision is aimed at ensuring that minor children of deceased parents receive financial support corresponding to their needs due to the loss of their parent.

Contention

The bill's introduction may spark controversy regarding the balance between restitution and rehabilitation. While supporters may argue that this bill provides necessary support for grieving families, critics could highlight the potential for excessive financial burdens on offenders, particularly if they are unable to secure employment due to their criminal convictions. Additionally, concerns may arise over how these restitution orders will be enforced, especially if the offender is incarcerated or lacks the financial means to comply. There may also be discussions on whether this legislation appropriately addresses the issues of public safety and victim compensation in a comprehensive manner.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

IA H3287

Driving and boating under the influence

IA HB1574

Motor vehicles; certain convictions of homicide by vehicle when operating such vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs; require restitution

IA HB986

Requires child support payments by persons convicted of vehicular homicide

IA SB94

Requiring a person convicted of an offense that resulted in the incapacitation or death of a victim who is the parent or guardian of a minor child to pay restitution in the form of child support.

IA HB1394

Criminal Law – Homicide by Motor Vehicle or Vessel – Restitution to Child (Bentley’s Law)

IA HB994

Provides relative to the payment of restitution from offenders convicted of vehicular homicide under certain circumstances

IA HB2196

Mandating restitution to children of victims of negligent homicide or driving under the influence causing death

IA HB712

Provide for restitution payments to children of certain homicide victims

IA HB336

Enact the Sam Knisley Family Support Act

IA H2038

To require restitution for a child whose parent is killed by a drunk driver

Similar Bills

AZ SB1189

Criminal restitution orders; interest

TX SB1666

Relating to the payment of restitution.

WV SB14

Authorizing restitution to victims of securities fraud

WV SB63

Authorizing restitution to victims of securities fraud

AL HB559

Fraud victims compensation; Market Accountability Compensation Fund, established to provide restitution assistance to victims of investment fraud

CA AB2297

Restitution: diversion.

AZ HB2825

fines; fees; assessments; restitution; nonpayment

CA AB1213

Restitution: priority.