Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SR20

Caption

Amending The Rules Of The Senate To Establish That A Failure To Submit To A Breathalyzer Test, Blood Test, Or Field Sobriety Test During A Lawful Stop Shall Be Grounds For Expulsion.

Impact

If adopted, SR20 would formally lay out the consequences of refusal to comply with sobriety tests for legislators, specifically allowing for an expulsion process under Article III, Section 12 of the Hawaii State Constitution. This amendment would require legislators to lead by example, reinforcing the idea that those in power must act responsibly, particularly regarding public safety issues like drunk driving. Through this resolution, the legislature aims to foster a culture of accountability among its members, ensuring that they are subjected to the same principles governing the safety of the public they serve.

Summary

Senate Resolution 20 (SR20) proposes an amendment to the rules of the Hawaii State Senate, establishing that a failure by any member of the legislature to submit to a breathalyzer test, blood test, or field sobriety test during a lawful stop by a law enforcement officer will be considered an act of misconduct. This measure is grounded in the belief that legislators, as public figures, should adhere to higher standards of conduct, especially concerning public safety measures like intoxicated driving tests. The resolution emphasizes that safe roads are vital to everyday life and that intoxicated drivers pose significant risks to this safety.

Contention

Within the discussions surrounding SR20, notable points of contention may arise regarding the specific implications of holding legislators to higher standards. Critics might argue that imposing such measures could create an environment of fear or mistrust, where lawmakers might feel pressured to comply for fear of expulsion. Additionally, concerns may be voiced regarding the practicality and fairness of the enforcement of such rules, especially in assessing the circumstances of each case. Supporters, however, would likely counter that such measures are necessary for ensuring accountability among elected officials, which can strengthen public trust in government institutions.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

OK SR26

Resolution; supporting SB 1640; urging expeditious committee and floor consideration; and affirming the Senate's commitment to enforcing its rules and the Oklahoma Constitution.

WA HB1426

Creating a civil protection order to prevent impaired driving.

MD HB946

Motor Vehicle Administration - Breathalyzer Technology - Uniform Standards

MD HB0946

State Government - Governor's Appointments Office - Judicial Selection - Reporting

OK SB1218

Alcoholic beverage license; removing reference to personal use permit. Effective date.

OK SB1192

Alcohol and drug substance abuse counseling; increasing certain alcohol and drug assessment and evaluation fee. Effective date.

OK SB1767

Alcoholic beverages; prohibiting retailer from shipping alcoholic beverages; allowing Attorney General to enforce provisions; allowing ABLE Commission to initiate investigations; creating revolving fund. Effective date. Emergency.

OK SB1442

Alcoholic beverage license fees; providing certain production limits; establishing exception to certain licensing requirements; limiting fine amounts. Effective date.