Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SCR11

Introduced
1/25/23  

Caption

Urging The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands To Notify Beneficiaries Through Beneficiary Consultation Prior To Disposing Of Hawaiian Home Lands And To Exercise Other Protections Of Beneficiary Interests.

Impact

The resolution's emphasis on beneficiary consultation mandates that the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands must conduct an interactive process wherein beneficiaries are informed and can provide input before any significant disposal of lands occurs. This could potentially enhance transparency and trust between the Department and the communities it serves. Moreover, it encourages the Department to refrain from leases to non-beneficiaries unless there are insufficient applicants, thereby prioritizing Native Hawaiian interests in land management.

Summary

Senate Concurrent Resolution 11 (SCR11) urges the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands to enhance communication and consultation with beneficiaries before disposing of Hawaiian Home Lands. This resolution stems from the historical context of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act of 1921, which aimed to benefit Native Hawaiians by restoring their cultural connections to land and providing housing stability. SCR11 reinforces accountability in the Department's dealings regarding land management and acknowledges the significance of beneficiary consultation as a mechanism to ensure that the voices of indigenous Hawaiians are heard in decisions affecting their lands.

Contention

Key areas of contention may arise from concerns about the balance between land management efficiency and safeguarding indigenous rights. Proponents of the resolution argue that it is necessary to protect the interests of Native Hawaiians and ensure that their voices are not overlooked in bureaucratic decisions. Critics, however, might argue that extensive consultation requirements could slow down necessary land management processes and impair economic opportunities by complicating leasing arrangements with multiple stakeholders.

Additional_points

Furthermore, SCR11 stipulates that the Department should furnish regular updates to beneficiaries and the legislature regarding inventory and disposition status of lands, enhancing the overall accountability and engagement of the Department with the community. This resolution represents a step towards curbing the historical marginalization of Native Hawaiian interests by fostering a consultation framework that respects their rights and needs.

Companion Bills

HI SR9

Same As Urging The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands To Notify Beneficiaries Through Beneficiary Consultation Prior To Disposing Of Hawaiian Home Lands And To Exercise Other Protections Of Beneficiary Interests.

Similar Bills

HI HR115

Requesting The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands And Statewide Office On Homelessness And Housing Solutions To Develop A Coordinated Support And Stabilization Pathway For Native Hawaiian Beneficiaries Experiencing Homelessness Or Extremely Low Income.

HI SR88

Requesting The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands And Statewide Office On Homelessness And Housing Solutions To Develop A Coordinated Support And Stabilization Pathway For Native Hawaiian Beneficiaries Experiencing Homelessness Or Extremely Low Income.

HI SCR93

Requesting The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands And Statewide Office On Homelessness And Housing Solutions To Develop A Coordinated Support And Stabilization Pathway For Native Hawaiian Beneficiaries Experiencing Homelessness Or Extremely Low Income.

HI HCR123

Requesting The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands And Statewide Office On Homelessness And Housing Solutions To Develop A Coordinated Support And Stabilization Pathway For Native Hawaiian Beneficiaries Experiencing Homelessness Or Extremely Low Income.

HI SR13

Requesting The Office Of The Auditor To Conduct A Performance Audit Of The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands Paper Lease System.

HI SCR15

Requesting The Office Of The Auditor To Conduct A Performance Audit Of The Department Of Hawaiian Home Lands Paper Lease System.

HI HB410

Relating To The Budget Of The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.

HI SB625

Relating To Hawaiian Home Lands.