Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii House Resolution HR71

Introduced
3/9/23  
Refer
3/15/23  
Report Pass
3/30/23  

Caption

Requesting Collaboration To Update Chapter 343, Hawaii Revised Statutes, To Reflect All Factors That Shall Be Considered For The Environmental Impact Statement Process, And Requesting Public Forums To Be Held On The Future Use Of State Lands Currently Leased To The Military.

Impact

The implementation of HR71 proposes significant changes to how environmental assessments related to military lands would be conducted. By proposing to require independent reviews, the bill aims to uphold the integrity and reliability of the findings regarding potential environmental impacts. This change could enhance public trust in the decision-making process, particularly amidst concerns regarding previous practices where hired entities may have influenced outcomes in favor of the military's interests. Additionally, public forums are mandated to engage local communities in discussions about the land's future use, fostering greater transparency and community input into the decision-making process.

Summary

House Resolution 71 (HR71) seeks to address the upcoming expiration of the United States Army's lease on approximately 23,000 acres of land on Hawaii Island, which is set to conclude in August 2029. The resolution requests a collaborative effort to amend Chapter 343 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes in order to enhance the environmental impact statement process. This amendment would ensure that all relevant factors, such as Hawaiian culture, engineering considerations, and environmental design, are comprehensively included in the review process for any proposed future use of the land in question. An essential aspect of this initiative is to prevent potential conflicts of interest, ensuring that independent reviews rather than partisan interests dictate the findings of environmental assessments.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HR71 appears to be largely positive among advocates for environmental health and social justice. Supporters contend that an independent review process is essential for protecting the environment and ensuring that local cultural values are respected. However, skepticism remains regarding the military's and state government's willingness to cooperate fully with these independent assessments. The call for public forums also elicits mixed feelings; while it is seen as a step towards greater community engagement, some fear that the military's interests may still overshadow local feedback.

Contention

While HR71 advocates for collaboration and transparency, it may encounter pushback from military entities and governmental agencies concerned about the operational implications of stronger oversight on land use. Critics of the bill may express worries that an extended review process could delay important projects or initiatives that depend on the use of these lands. Balancing local community interests with military operational needs represents a core contention point that will need careful navigation as this resolution moves forward.

Companion Bills

HI HCR70

Same As Requesting Collaboration To Update Chapter 343, Hawaii Revised Statutes, To Reflect All Factors That Shall Be Considered For The Environmental Impact Statement Process, And Requesting Public Forums To Be Held On The Future Use Of State Lands Currently Leased To The Military.

Similar Bills

CA AB1288

Registered environmental health specialists.

MI HB4961

Education: curriculum; environmental literacy task force to develop environmental literacy model curriculum and report on the curriculum; provide for. Amends 1976 PA 451 (MCL 380.1 - 380.1852) by adding sec. 1159.

DE HCR118

Designating April 22nd To The 26th, 2024 As National Environmental Education Week In The State Of Delaware.

WA HB1347

Integrating community-based health assessments into foundational environmental policies to improve environmental justice.

IL SB1686

ENVIRONMENTAL PARTICIPATION

CA AB2722

Motor Vehicle Fuel Tax Law: suspension of tax.

AZ SB1581

Environmental quality; task force

NC S616

Environmental Health Associates