Alabama 2024 Regular Session

Alabama Senate Bill SB32

Introduced
2/6/24  
Introduced
2/6/24  
Report Pass
2/28/24  
Refer
2/6/24  
Refer
3/6/24  
Report Pass
2/28/24  
Report Pass
3/20/24  
Refer
3/6/24  
Enrolled
5/9/24  
Report Pass
3/20/24  
Passed
5/17/24  
Enrolled
5/9/24  
Passed
5/17/24  

Caption

Retirement benefits, revise circumstances when an individual's pension, annuity, or retirement allowance benefits are subject to certain recovery actions

Impact

The bill's impact centers on the rights of retirees who receive pension benefits. Under the modified provisions, if a retiree is subject to a restitution order that meets the stipulated criteria, up to 25% of their gross monthly benefit may be diverted to satisfy such obligations. This represents a significant shift from previous protections that exempted pension benefits from garnishment and other forms of financial recovery, making it easier for courts to enforce restitution orders against retirees, especially those involved in serious criminal offenses.

Summary

SB32 aims to amend the existing provisions under the Teachers' Retirement System and the Employees' Retirement System concerning the recovery of funds related to pension, annuity, or retirement benefits. The bill specifies new circumstances under which these benefits can be subjected to restitution orders for financial obligations stemming from criminal cases. Specifically, it allows for recovery actions against retirees' pension benefits when they have been ordered by a court to pay restitution amounts of $1,000 or greater, provided certain conditions are met.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB32 appears to lean towards support from lawmakers who prioritize accountability in the criminal justice system and believe that financial responsibilities should extend into retirement. However, there may be concerns from retiree advocacy groups about the potential financial strain on those who may have already limited income due to retirement status. Stakeholders are likely to debate the fairness of reclaiming funds from pensions, balancing the need for criminal restitution against the rights of retired individuals.

Contention

Notable points of contention may surround the specifics of the bill, particularly with regard to the criteria for when funds can be seized and the potential consequences for retirees who face such actions. Critics may argue that the bill disproportionately affects lower-income retirees and undermines the security of their retirement funds, which are typically intended to be shielded from creditors. Furthermore, the bill could draw scrutiny on the broader implications it has on the treatment of retirees within the criminal justice framework, especially in cases where dependency on such benefits is essential for basic living costs.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

AL HB312

District Attorneys’ Plan for Retirement under the Judicial Retirement Fund; calculation of service retirement allowance and disability retirement allowance revised; limitation on amount of service retirement allowance compared to member's average final compensation revised

AL H5762

Recalculates the retirement allowance related to early retirement and pension benefits for teachers, state employees and municipal employees.

AL S0659

Recalculates the retirement allowance related to early retirement and pension benefits for teachers, state employees and municipal employees.

AL A2449

Requires cost of living increase to be granted in each of two State fiscal years when retirement allowance or benefit is below certain amount for retiree or beneficiary in PERS, TPAF, PFRS, SPRS, and JRS; makes appropriation.

AL S1448

Requires cost of living increase to be granted in each of two State fiscal years when retirement allowance or benefit is below certain amount for retiree or beneficiary in PERS, TPAF, PFRS, SPRS, and JRS; makes appropriation.

AL HB1209

For The Proper Administration Of Benefits By The Arkansas Judicial Retirement System Regarding The Subjection Of Annuity Rights To Process Of Law And Correction Of Errors.

AL S2090

Changes the retirement allowance based on accrued benefits.

AL H7444

Changes the retirement allowance based on accrued benefits.

AL S0410

Changes the retirement allowance based on accrued benefits.

AL H5700

Changes the retirement allowance based on accrued benefits.

Similar Bills

AZ SB1189

Criminal restitution orders; interest

TX SB1666

Relating to the payment of restitution.

WV SB14

Authorizing restitution to victims of securities fraud

WV SB63

Authorizing restitution to victims of securities fraud

AL HB559

Fraud victims compensation; Market Accountability Compensation Fund, established to provide restitution assistance to victims of investment fraud

CA AB2297

Restitution: diversion.

AZ HB2825

fines; fees; assessments; restitution; nonpayment

CA AB1213

Restitution: priority.